Your top five cigars (N/C)

[Mississippi Rifleman]

The "Other things you do" thread inspired this one. What are you top five favorite cigars that you smoke?

1. Ashton VSG
2. Ashton Cabinet
3. Perdomo Champagne
4. Punch Gran Puro
5. Torano Exodus 1959 Gold

Honorable mentions:
Other Toranos, All CAOs, Excaliburs (both regular and 1066)

Favorite sizes are the robusto followed by the corona.

[Jwrussell]

My top 5 so far from my limited experience:

Edit: if we are including "other" cigars, then: RyJ No. 4 is so far my top number 1.

1. Torano Sig
2. Torano Exodus Gold
3. Ashton VSG
4. Monte Serie V
5. CAO Brazilia

Every one of these is based off of a single stick, though I have plenty more of the Sig to enjoy. I have one more Exodus Gold in the humi as well. I expect this list will soon be completely outdated as I have some PAMs, WOAMs, and other AF Hemis resting.

I just received an Excalibur 1066 from buymorecigars.com when they sent out their new catalog. Can't wait to try it.

[Jwrussell]

Quick question, I figured we were only talking NCs considering the forum, no?

[Mississippi Rifleman]

Quick question, I figured we were only talking NCs considering the forum, no?

Nah. I only did N/Cs because that were all my experience lies.

[Mali]

here are mine to date.. (no particular order)

Olivo O Bold - Ole
Drew Estate - The Early Years - Silencio
CoRo
RyJ Habana (not exactly sure which it was)
Indian Tabac Camaroon Legend
Monte Cristo Robusto

[dbaranska]

I have to go with:

Diploma Maduro
Diploma Corojo
Rocky Patel 1992
Perdomo Champagne
Tarano 1959 gold

But there are so many others......

[coma]

:oops: BOOBOO!!

here's my list:


PAM (ofcoarse, if you consider it a N/C, I don't)
Anejo #55
Opus Power Ranger xXx
WOAM
El Rico Habano Maduro
....and since PAM's are on the border I pick 858 SG

:P

[JgButler]

PAM 1964
Ashton VSG
Padron 5000
Padron 2000
La Luna

[tedski]

Avo 22
Davidoff Millenium
Hemingway maduro
La Luna African Fuerte (new addition)
Partagas Spanish Rosado

[Jwrussell]

Avo 22
Davidoff Millenium
Hemingway maduro
Mayorga maduro
Partagas Spanish Rosado

I've seen those AVO 22's advertised before...post us a review if you get to smoke another anytime soon?

[tedski]

Here you go jw ...

http://www.botl.org/community/forum/viewtopic.php?p=2434#2434

[Jwrussell]

:smt023

Very nice, sounds like one awesome cigar.

[Pulse]

1. Gurkha Masters Select - Double Corona
2. Oliva "O" Ole
3. CAO MX2
4. Opus X
5. Oliva Masters Blend or RyJ Bully (this was a tie for me)

8)

[David]

Basically any PAM, Fuente, or Torano.

[Bsslack]

These are always tough descisions because tastes change.

But Lately here's my 5 Favorite Doms

Opus Power Ranger

AVO 22

Don Carlos (any)

AF Hemingway Classic

Torano Signature Toro


They never fail to satisfy, I have had alot of Hit and Miss experiences with several Brands and Smokes. This group is Always there to consistantly supply a Quality experience.

Cheers Men!



Slack 8)

[DocRKS]

PAM Serie 1964 Torpedo
PAM Serie 1964 Imperial
Davidoff Millenium Series
Opus X Double Corona
Diamond Crown Grande Torpedo

Even though my personal Humi is 90%+ of the Darkside - my smoking experience and enjoyment would be GREATLY diminished if these awesome Non-Habana cigars were not available.... In fact, the Padron 64s are on my list of "if you were stranded on a desert island with only 5 cigars - what cigars would they be ?"

[smokinafuente]

These are always tough descisions because tastes change.

But Lately here's my 5 Favorite Doms

Opus Power Ranger

AVO 22

Don Carlos (any)

AF Hemingway Classic

Torano Signature Toro


They never fail to satisfy, I have had alot of Hit and Miss experiences with several Brands and Smokes. This group is Always there to consistantly supply a Quality experience.

Cheers Men!



Slack 8)


I'll have to keep this in mind. :twisted:



Mine would have to be ( in no order)

'04 Torano Tribute - Robusto
A Fuente - Double Chateau SG
La Gloria Cubana Serie R #7
Joya de Nicaragua Antaño 1970
Cao Italia - Ciao
(and since cigar smokers can't count, no one will notice #6)
A Fuente - Canones Maduro

[sb1396]

2 votes for Anejo
PAM's
Fuente SG's
WOAM

[Garnivore]

Montecristo Robustos
Ashton Cabinet #6 or Pyramid
Fuente Hemingway Short Story
Fuente 8-5-8 maduro
Fuente Chateau mad or nat
Torano Casa robusto

I guess I can't count!! :lol:

[Poni]

Asthon VSG
Gurkha Legend
CAO Maduro
CAO Black
Partagas Cifuentes Seasonal

...honorable mentions...
Partagas Spanish Rosados and Blacks
Gurkha Regents

:smt033

[sucol]

1. Anejo
2. Opus X
3. PAM
4. Padron Maduro
5. CAO Brazilia
CAO Mx2

Tie for number 5 - could not help myself!

[sucol]

But where do I work in VSG? Dern Fuentes ... :?

[geoffrie]

PAM 64 Torpeso
Davidoff Millenium robusto
Anejo 55
Camacaho 11/18
DC Maximus Churchill #2

[Bum Fudge]

No particular order...

Cao Brazilia - Ipanema
Torano 1959
Ghurka Regent
Hemingway Best Seller or SS
La Gloria Cubana Serie R #5 tied with Joya de Nicaragua Antaño 1970

I have some of the others you all listed coming up in the rotation so I expect my list to change soon as I get some more under my belt.

[ehdg]

PAM 26
PAM 64
Rocky Patel Vintage '90
Rocky Patel Vintage '92
La Aurora Perfecto #2

ehdg

[Cigar_Jack]

Rocky Patel Edge Maduro Torpedo
La Aurora Perfecto #2
Casa Torano Robusto
Torano Signature Torpedo
CAO Cameroon

[althekillr]

Top 5 cigars

1. Oliva "0" Original
2. Connie 112
3. Padron 2000 m
4. Torano 1916
5. La Luna's

With the exception of the oliva, I go to domestics for value. if it costs over $4 per stick, then I'd rather just any number of isoms' for the same price.

[mark5]

Pam64's
anejo sharks
Padron 2000 maduro
Torano 59 golds
CAO Brazilla

[Halon]

CAO Brazilia
Onyx Reserve
Gurkha Legend
Bucanero Peg Leg
Not sure what I'd put as my fifth choice.
I haven't ever tried the more expensive stuff like opus, anejo, fuente, or Rocky Patel, so my list might be a little bit skewed.


TYLER

[cf2112]

the Darkside is where I spend most of my time but these are some I still enjoy

PAM
Padron 3000 Mad or Nat
Anejo's any
858sg
Opus PL or xXx