Your Opinion is Requested

[eyetek]

I have been wanting to create a Cigar Dossier to have a place to save my reviews of the cigars I smoke, so I went out today and bought a leather binder and began to create a evaluation page for each different cigar.

Here is were you come in to play, take a look at this draft and tell me what you think..what I forgot to include or what I should leave out.

Thanks for your help.

eyetek

[Angry Bill]

I have been wanting to create a Cigar Dossier to have a place to save my reviews of the cigars I smoke, so I went out today and bought a leather binder and began to create a evaluation page for each different cigar.

Here is were you come in to play, take a look at this draft and tell me what you think..what I forgot to include or what I should leave out.

Thanks for your help.

eyetek

Ah, Bro, there is nothing to check out! Oh no! Have you been drinking while you have been creative. I hate that! lol.. :glassesgr

[eyetek]

Damn...the site has a Word Doc file size max of 19.5 KB and this file is 49KB.... I will work on getting this posted.

eyetek

[eyetek]

Ah, Bro, there is nothing to check out! Oh no! Have you been drinking while you have been creative. I hate that! lol.. :glassesgr

You got it...drinking and watching the game and playing on the laptop....:nono:

eyetek

[eyetek]

Ok, here it is, I had to zip it so you will have to unzip it....LOL

Let me know what you think.

eyetek

[Angry Bill]

I like the form. It is similar to Colin Ganley's form, but is easier. And, I like the fact that you have a spot for the band. Nice going!

[eyetek]

I like the form. It is similar to Colin Ganley's form, but is easier. And, I like the fact that you have a spot for the band. Nice going!

Thanks, I found his evaluation sheet and one other one online and combined the two to create what i wanted to see in a review.

eyetek

[GatorMike]

Very nice. Seems easy to use and well laid out.

[Angry Bill]

Mind if I use it?

[jmatkins]

Looks good to me, nice work.

[eyetek]

Mind if I use it?

Sure you can, anyone can use it if they want.

eyetek

[oneaday]

Just a question from someone that has never documented cigar smoking.
Would you evaluate every cigar you smoke or just the extrodinary cigars, one each boxcode of a marca ??????

[no_substitute]

atmosphire = atmosphere

Seems to add a lot of work to relaxing and enjoying cigars, but if you're into this sorta thing, cool. :crosseyed

[eyetek]

atmosphire = atmosphere

Seems to add a lot of work to relaxing and enjoying cigars, but if you're into this sorta thing, cool. :crosseyed

LOL...see what drinking and watching football while trying to work does to a man!

I do not plan to use it for every cigar I smoke every day...but for those special days or when smoking a special cigar it seems like a good way to record the cigar and the moment to reflect on later.

eyetek

[eyetek]

just the extrodinary cigars, one each boxcode of a marca ??????

Exactly!

eyetek

[eyetek]

I may try to create another draft, this time in an attempt to make the evaluation easier with a bit less effort but still include the same info, maybe some multiple choice questions or even a "check this box" kind of answers!

Will post my results later!

eyetek

[vperlman]

Just a question from someone that has never documented cigar smoking.
Would you evaluate every cigar you smoke or just the extrodinary cigars, one each boxcode of a marca ??????
I try to keep a record of at lease one sample of each vitola I smoke, regardless of how good, bad, rare, etc. it might be. That way, I know what to look for and what to avoid. If I smoke a sample that I feel is noticeably different from the comments in my diary on a previous sample, I will add that to my notes. Otherwise, I just leave the comments on the first sample as is.

Hope this helps.

[CWS]

Just a question from someone that has never documented cigar smoking.
Would you evaluate every cigar you smoke or just the extrodinary cigars, one each boxcode of a marca ??????

Good question. My kids had a beautiful ledger custom made for me for Christmas. Leather bound and printed with my name etc. I figured I would use it for those really spcial cigars or times.

[David]

Looks great!

That being said, entirely to much work for me.

[eyetek]

Looks great!

That being said, entirely to much work for me.

Well then you may enjoy the next version :stretchgr

eyetek

[David]

Well then you may enjoy the next version :stretchgr

eyetek

I keep a dossier but use the standard version which is much simpler than your creation. I think yours looks great but I have a tough time keeping up with mine!

Amazon.com: Cigar Dossier: Everything Else

[eyetek]

I keep a dossier but use the standard version which is much simpler than your creation. I think yours looks great but I have a tough time keeping up with mine!

Amazon.com: Cigar Dossier: Everything Else (http://www.amazon.com/Cigar-Dossier/dp/B000GJQ9KU)

I looked at just buying that one and decided to give this a try first.

I have created a rough draft of another review sheet, this one is just a check the box that fits your observation, take a look at this one and let me know what your thoughts are.

Oh and if anyone can get the damn boxes to line up in a straight line please feel free to help out!

eyetek

[tubaman]

I smoke and enjoy. That's too much like homework for me. The extra special cigars make me want to concentrate even more on them, so I don't want to take the time to write things down. But that's me. Have fun with it!