My thoughts...
Don Pepin Brands:
- Black Label - Cuban Classic (my favorite Pepin-brand cigar)
- Blue Label (very good, especially in the smaller ring gauges)
- White Label - Series JJ (very potent, one of the best Pepins)
- White Label - Series JJ Maduro (excellent, rich and strong)
- Vegas Cubanas (affordable, one of my faves)
- El Rey de los Habanos (affordable, one of the mildest Pepins)
- El Centurion (limited release, might be hard to find now)
- Tabaccos Baez (I haven't had one yet)
Don Pepin Client Brands:
- Tatuaje Brown Label (my favorite Pepin-made cigars)
- Tatuaje Havana IV Red Label (milder than browns, but totally fantastic)
- Tatuaje Series P White Label (cheap "sandwich" but awesome flavor)
- Cabaiguan by Tatuaje (nice, but mild. Not my favorite wrapper leaf)
- La Riqueza by Tatuaje (awesome new maduro, loving these)
- Ashton San Cristóbal (my second favorite Pepin-made cigar)
- Ashton Benchmade (excellent value stick)
- EO 601 line (4 versions)
- EO Cubao (relatively new stick, I'm loving them right now)
- CI Legends Yellow (didn't do anything for me)
- CI 5 Vegas Miami (quite decent, no similarities to other 5 Vegas lines)
- Holt's Old Henry (surprisingly rich tasting, good value)
- Holt's DPJ Fumadores (holy smokes these are cheap!)
- Holt's Connoisseur Selection (I know nothing about them)
- Holt's Casa Royale (I know nothing about them)
There are some other Client-brands out there, especially a lot of one-time releases. To be honest, 90% of what Pepin makes I thoroughly enjoy, but a lot of that is because I'm really into Nicaraguan tobaco.