Hmm, I've tried some of those cigars....
Davidoff Aniversario Robusto 100
It was okay, but nothing to get too terribly excited about. Very subtle cigar, so it's something you need to sit down and really pay attention to, otherwise you'll likely miss out on what it has to offer.
Partagas 160
Ugh, quite possible the most disappointing new release in years for me. Truly a bland, lifeless flavor. I've gotten more flavor out of chewing on a toothpick.
H. Upmann Signature
Haven't had one yet, but I've been on the lookout. My b&m ran out, and when I saw them at a different b&m their box had been water damaged. Doh! I do plan on smoking one tho, I've heard really good things about it.
Augusto Reyes Criollo
Never even heard of it??? Adding it to my "buy" list now.
Camacho Liberty 2006
Okay cigar, not nearly as full bodied as their typical cigars (that's a good thing, some of their cigars are obnoxiously strong) but it's not great...and not as tasty as some of the previous Liberty cigars (04 was my fav)
Fonseca Cubano Limitado
Not a bad stick at all. I wouldn't go so far as to call it one of the "best" of the year, but it was enjoyable.
Gurkha Beauty
Haven't had one, and honestly don't plan to try. For some reason, Gurkhas don't typically agree with my personal flavor preference.
RP Olde World Reserve
Ooo, now THESE are cigars I really like! The maduro is good, but the corojo is the better stick. Fairly strong, but not overboard. Flavor is similar to the RP Vintage series, but with more oomph.
The Macanudo Vintage 2000 Cabinet Selection
I keep seeing these in stores, and I keep walking right on by them. Not on my "buy" list, don't plan to add it anytime soon, either.