Blind reviews! - updated 1st post

[Fourtotheflush]

Be on the lookout!
Blind reviews coming soon!

Please if you immediately recognize a stick do not call it out until it has been revealed!

Each participant will be posting their own review thread per stick so it can be attached to their account.

Cigar A: Man O' War Puro Authentico (for me, and many I know, this is a great quick every day smoke)

Jdog - http://www.botl.in/58262

Docb - http://www.botl.in/58295

TNT - http://www.botl.in/58293

JavaJ - http://www.botl.in/58230

Mathen - http://www.botl.in/58193

Cigar B: Ok, so I thought I was pulling off a little trickery here.
Half the panel got: My Father Cedros Deluxe (one of my favorite, if not favorite, DPG cigars)
Half the panel got: Oliva V Especial Maduro 2011 (one of my most anticipated annual releases)

TNT - http://www.botl.in/58432

JavaJ - http://www.botl.in/58394

JDog - http://www.botl.in/58387

Mathen - http://www.botl.in/58384

DocB - http://www.botl.in/58484

Cigar C: As some have guessed or come close to, it is an Undercrown Toro Gorda.

Jdog - http://www.botl.in/58556

Javajunkie - http://www.botl.in/58530

Docb - http://www.botl.in/58721

Mathen - http://www.botl.in/58740

 

[Mathen]

Oops! Re-read the instructions to start my review and realized I forgot to to post the photo of all the sticks. Let me remedy that!

 

[Mathen]

...And in my haste I posted this in the WRONG FREAKING THREAD. Please ignore.

 

[Zedman05]

^ :hammersma:rofl:

 

[Fourtotheflush]

Ok so 4/6 have posted cigar A's review.

At this point I think it is rather obvious what cigar A is.
But I will wait until the last two post and I will reveal!

Cigar B & C should get more interesting!

 

[JDog]

Ok so 4/6 have posted cigar A's review.

At this point I think it is rather obvious what cigar A is.
But I will wait until the last two post and I will reveal!

Cigar B & C should get more interesting!

Was I not suppose to reveal my guess... sorry if I did too soon.

 

[Docbp87]

Was I not suppose to reveal my guess... sorry if I did too soon.

Premature ejaculator.

 

[javajunkie]

hey flushy, should i move mine to NSFW? o)

 

[JDog]

Premature ejaculator.

:nodlaugh:Yeah I'm going to actually do a pre and post guess on each cigar... even send my guesses prior to Neil prior to lighting it up... I'm probably going to look like a fool on these other sticks...

 

[Docbp87]

:nodlaugh:Yeah I'm going to actually do a pre and post guess on each cigar... even send my guesses prior to Neil prior to lighting it up... I'm probably going to look like a fool on these other sticks...

Same. I knew what the first was before smoking, but the other two could be a million different sticks...

 

[Fourtotheflush]

Ok so still waiting on Jim to post up, but
Cigar A is in fact Man O War Puro Authentico!
Kind of a layup there as the look alone could reveal a ton about this cigar!

Now don't worry about reading everyone else's reviews for cigars B&C!
You may or may not have the same cigar as your fellow panelists!

 

[Fourtotheflush]

I have updated the 1st post with Links to the individual reviews.

 

[strife]

I have updated the 1st post with Links to the individual reviews.

They all go to the same post (JDogs) for me. :scratchhe

 

[z6joker9]

I'm probably going to look like a fool on these other sticks...

I did a blind 6er on my vacation week over the holidays (from a botl on another forum)... I was surprised that I managed to put them in general order of quality! And I found a nice $4-5 box-worthy stick to boot!

 

[Fourtotheflush]

They all go to the same post (JDogs) for me. :scratchhe

Ok,
so I think I need a little help here!

I put all the links in there properly.

I go look at them and in the edit screen they are all correct.

but when I save they all link to my 1st URL?

Any help would be appreciated here.

 

[Fourtotheflush]

Thanks for the fix!

 

[Fourtotheflush]

Ok, Cigar B
or should I say Cigars B have been revealed.

See 1st post for the reveal!

 

[strife]

Thanks for sponsoring this Neil, I'm really enjoying the reviews. :smokingbo

 

[Fourtotheflush]

I hope everyone is enjoying it as much as me!
Because I am loving it!

 

[javajunkie]

the guessing is frustrating as hell, but fun! the smoking, THAT i am loving! hella' selection, and i am not sure i would have found that man'o'war on my own. thanks again!