I've used it 3 or four times and posted in the cigar deals thread.(actually it got moved there and thats why I posted somewhere else so it could be easily traced back)
I believe I got several great deals and a couple good deals.
RP old world Reserve 50 ct chest Msrp $500.00 cheapest ever found was 250.00 2 months ago at CI. Got them for $210.00.
La Aurora Puro Salomones 8 for 200.00 MSRP (only 12,000 ever made) paid 125.00. 2 boxes
Those were a few i remember.
Heres my theory unless they're one of the select few boxes (Partagas 160) start low really low you get 3 offers a day unless they have few left or are extremely collectable no need to overpay. If its a box valued at 200.00 look around at cigar bid and CI. Get a Idea of cost then start to chisel away at price 65.00 then 80. then 85. next day 88.00 93.00 96.00 so on. I havent bought any of the samplers in my eyes unless theyre going to give them away you can get samplers or fivers at CI or Cigabid for dirtcheap. For 10 pack or boxes I think you can get a good deal.