What's new
  • BOTL UPCOMING MAINTENANCE

    Hi Everyone, as mentioned in my introduction post, BOTL needs quite a bit of updating, patching and whatever else I might come across. Over time BOTL may be unreachable on occasion as I do migrations or updates, etc. Just be patient - we'll be back! I'll generally try to keep these maintenances until later in the evenings.

Double review: Hemingway Best Seller & T-Rex 100th *Pic heavy*

Rating - 100%
5   0   0
Joined
Oct 11, 2010
Messages
180
Location
Montesano, WA
Today was one of those particularly great days. Worked the open shift at the coffee shop, got a ton of extra baking done, got up the 1/2 mile of uphill gravel driveway just minutes before the onset of our first snow of the year, grabbed a cup of coffee and a Hemingway Best Seller and headed out to the porch to enjoy the fresh air and rare snowfall.

Beautiful little perfecto, light brown wrapper, no major veins, smells lightly of cinnamon and tobacco. Paired with a black cup of Sisters Coffee Black Butte, lit with a Ronson JetLight, and cut with a Xikar X8.

Prelight draw is a little tight, but not bad and is to be expected considering the shape. Not much prelight flavor, sweet tobacco. Firm cigar, minimal give.

The goods:


The setting:


Cigar lights up quickly and effortlessly. First puffs are delightfully sweet. Tobacco and wood, there is some spice as well. The draw has already opened up considerably and is almost perfect. The smoke has a noticeable floral scent to it. Very pleasant.

Initial light:


First third is coming along great. Firm, beautiful ash, pleasant smoke. Flavors I'm getting are cinnamon, wood, and another form of sweetness. I think I'd call it a floral note. Only thing I can think of to accompany that undoubtedly floral smell. Admittedly, aside from the occasional violet, I don't eat many flowers. lol. Burn is going great.

First third:


During this whole experience, our goats aren't far away and are taking great pains to ensure that I'm aware of their displeasure with this strange, cold, flaky substance now pouring out of the sky. Some more company has also arrived. My youngest sister and my mother. My mother had the courtesy of joining me with a glass of whiskey for the remainder of the cigar and we talked about life and laughs and Plato's theory on love. Exceptionally rare to have my mother join me while I smoke, but an exceptionally enjoyable experience.

My furry friends:


My more articulate, but no more talkative company:


Coming into the second third the smoke is billowing from the cigar. Very dry finish. Cedar is present and the cinnamon still makes an occasional appearance, but that sweet floral taste, that so far in my experience seems to be a purely A. Fuente flavor, has come to the forefront along with a nutiness and a touch of leather. The ash has fallen, but it wasn't ready to do so of it's own accord; I tipped my camera over against it by accident.

2nd third:


Coming into the final third the flavors have stayed pretty steady. Still delicious, floral flavor is still the dominant flavor here, still sweet, but not as much as the first 2/3rds. Ash is holding strong, highlighting the great construction of this stick.

Final 3rd:


At the nub this cigar was still going strong. A slight bitterness entered the picture, but not much. My hands are chilled enough at this point that I'm having trouble operating my camera steadily enough to get a good picture and the camera seems to not want to do macro, but I took one anyway. I always think that one of the best signs that a cigar is great is that it's been nubbed properly. I could've gotten a bit more out of her, but I'd run out of coffee and had some people to meet up with.

Nearly mandatory nub shot:


Final smoke time was about 40 minutes. If you've never tried one of these cigars I would highly recommend that you fix that. I'd had a bad streak with A. Fuente at first, but these cigars changed my mind completely and a couple of the A. Fuente lines, the Hemingway being one of them, are now in my all time favorites.




Part 2

After finishing up the Best Seller I braved the driveway and went to meet some old friends I hadn't seen in quite some time for more coffee. A special blend by Olympia Coffee Roasters as it were.

After that I rushed home to grab a steak and an iced tea to go meet up with two of my best friends at the lake, one of whom had just got back into town after several months East of the Cascades.

I've just finally kicked a sinus infection that had been hanging around so I decided to break out my first Tatuaje Barclay Rex 100ths, which I've been dying to try. They smell amazing and I love the look to them, though I'll admit, they're not the prettiest sticks I've ever seen. Some of them are certainly gorgeous, but others don't have particularly even wrapper color and there are some prominent veins. Keep in mind that this is only an issue with a handful out of the box. Most look good. The good looking ones are absolutely gorgeous though. Rich brown wrapper, cute, pointy little pigtail, shaggy foot, just a touch of tooth to the one I'm smoking today.

Got to the lake early and decided to wolf down that steak while I had the chance. Took a picture with the T-Rex for good measure. Seemed appropriate. lol

T-Rex meat:


The lake:


My buddies get to the lake and we hike up to a little covered area in the woods. Prelight smell is heavy with chocolate and leather. Very enjoyable. Prelight draw gives hints of chocolate and cedar. Cuts easily with my Xikar X8. Took a while to light with my Ronson. Draw is a bit tight initially and it takes a minute to get some decent smoke produced which tasted very heavily of cedar with some spice and semi-sweetness to it. Even before the smoke really got going though, I could tell that this was going to be a damn good cigar.

T-Rex right before being set aflame.


Moving through the first third Cedar is definitely the predominant flavor along with some spice, but nowhere near as much as I'd anticipated from what I'd heard. Also tasted semi-sweet chocolate from time to time. The smoke is very thick and oily. It almost leaves a coat in your mouth. Very rich and just fantastic once it finally got going.

1/3rd going strong:

One of those heftier veins(Didn't affect the burn though):


The second third comes along looking great. The ash is hold great. At least two inches and the draw has gotten better. Burn is pretty even, but not the best. I touched it up just because I'm a tad OCD when it comes to burns.

Flavor has gotten a bit creamier. Cedar is still the predominant flavor, though there is some chocolate and nuttiness in there as well. The smoke is still thick and oily, almost chewy. It's sweeter than when I started and in the later part of the 1/3rd on into the 2/3rd there is a meatiness to it that is underlying everything. Finally lost the ash a little short of halfway through.

Nice ash:


Getting about halfway:


This final 3rd is where I started to get a little disappointed with the cigar. From the beginning of that 2nd third all the way through to the end, there has been little in the way of flavor change. That cedar is still very much there and very much dominant. Spice did come back, but when it did, it just stuck around and went right along with the cedar. It's not a bad flavor mind you, but it's getting wearisome. This is a very slow smoking cigar and I'm finding myself wishing it was about an inch and a half shorter at this point, because everything up to that point was phenomenal. I did a flame purge twice during the cigar hoping to get a decent change in taste, but even that didn't help as much as I'd have liked.

Final 3rd:


Light was getting scarce by the time I finished and I didn't nub this cigar like I normally would with something I enjoyed, so there's no nub shot on this one.

This cigar blew my mind for the first hour, but this smoke lasted for a little over two. It needed more change to keep me interested and I think with some more rest on these, they'll reach that full potential. The burn was good, the basic flavor was great, the smoke was rich, however, as it stands right now, I think this is a good cigar that is too much of a good thing. I'm glad I bought them, but I think I'm going to leave them be for a while before revisiting them. I'm glad I had friends there to help entertain me for that last stretch and the air was still enough for the most part to get some kickin' smoke rings, but with the lighting I couldn't get a decent shot of them.

I ended up polishing the evening off at my dad's for a birthday celebration, another steak dinner, and a little red wine. It was an amazing day and I've still got a smile on my face. Wanted to share some of it with you folks and I appreciate any of ya'll taking the time to read through all of my wordiness. Just one of those nights where I feel like writing I guess.
 
Rating - 100%
62   0   0
Joined
Oct 31, 2009
Messages
55,577
Location
DC/Tampa
Nice review. The Hemmingway’s are great cigars. This confirms that the t-rex needs the mandatory new tat rest.
 
Last edited:

SkinsFanLarry

Craft Beer Addict!
Rating - 100%
78   0   0
Joined
Oct 14, 2008
Messages
14,355
Jacob, most excellant review and pic's my friend, thanks for sharing the complete experience! :thumbsup:
 
Rating - 100%
8   0   0
Joined
Jul 17, 2010
Messages
1,791
Location
Philadelphia
That was picture perfect! I believe the cigar experience is under rated. It gets no better then this, sometimes when I get up in the morning and look outside take a quick glimpse and then open the door to get wiff of fresh air *aaaaaaaaaaahhhhhh* This is a great day for a cigar. The rest is history, Thanks for sharing this Wonderful Review & pics!

p.s - "My mother had the courtesy of joining me with a glass of whiskey for the remainder of the cigar and we talked about life and laughs and Plato's theory on love"
MoM knows how to throw it back huh??
 
Rating - 100%
5   0   0
Joined
Oct 11, 2010
Messages
180
Location
Montesano, WA
Man I really liked your pics and reviews...But that snow :frown: I'm just not ready!!
I hear you there my friend! I think the snow is beautiful, but we're not set up to deal with it on this side of the state. Once I leave my house, the only way back will be to hike. I'll get a nice 10:30 PM jaunt back up my hill once I get off work tonight.

p.s - "My mother had the courtesy of joining me with a glass of whiskey for the remainder of the cigar and we talked about life and laughs and Plato's theory on love"
MoM knows how to throw it back huh??
LOL. Yeah, she certainly knows how to enjoy a good drink without watering it down. Hell, she can probably still kick my ass too. :rolling:


And my thanks to everyone else for the kind words. :) I really enjoyed sharing.
 

Thegreekone

Banned
Rating - 100%
76   0   0
Joined
Aug 15, 2010
Messages
2,576
Location
Cleveland!
Jacob, as usual, another great that navigates the fine line between being passionate and laid back. Well done, bro. Thanks again! :thumbsup:
 
Rating - 98%
61   1   1
Joined
Jun 14, 2009
Messages
1,303
Location
Spring, TX
The AF Looked a bit short... was that the short story or best seller? You billed it as best seller, but man it looked a bit too small?

Great reviews for both sticks. Either way, those hemmingways are one of my fave go to lines. The info on the tat was cool as I have yet to try one.

Nice work.
 
Rating - 100%
5   0   0
Joined
Oct 11, 2010
Messages
180
Location
Montesano, WA
The AF Looked a bit short... was that the short story or best seller? You billed it as best seller, but man it looked a bit too small?

Great reviews for both sticks. Either way, those hemmingways are one of my fave go to lines. The info on the tat was cool as I have yet to try one.

Nice work.
Lol! Ya know, I spent a long time debating which it was. I've always got a handful of both sizes in my main humi, but I didn't have it with me yesterday and only had my travel humidor. I had been pretty sure that I had grabbed a Best Seller instead of a Shorty Story, but it did seem a little shorter than normal. I have seen some of the Best Sellers that weren't quite 5" though. I eventually just compared it to the T-Rex to see what the RG was and it was pretty close to the same width so I figured that it may have been a slightly shorter than usual Best Seller, but I can't say for sure. lol. :)

As a short side note, I used an LFD Tubo No. 100 to carry my T-Rex in after I pulled it out of the humi and slipped it into my coat. It fit like a glove. Perfect length and just thick enough that it had some pressure on the band to keep it from sliding at all. Thought it was kinda nifty how well it fit.



Jacob, as usual, another great that navigates the fine line between being passionate and laid back. Well done, bro. Thanks again! :thumbsup:
Thanks Jack :) I'm passionate about this hobby since it allows me to take the time to be laid back. Get the best of both worlds. :skew:
 
Rating - 0%
0   0   0
Joined
Oct 26, 2010
Messages
13
Location
Kansas City
Great reviews! I bought a box of the t-rex and have gone through 9 already. I wake up in the morning and have to restrain myself from having one pre-wheaties. Wish I had bought a second box (too rich for my blood at the moment). Also, heard about the Hem. work of art maduro and calles b-rex to see if they had any in stock. Adam shipped a 5-fiver to me today. Hope they are as good as I have heard. Anyone else smoked this stick?
 
Top