Most consistent brand and cigar
- Thread starter agulerer
- Start date
ChuckMejia
The General
Glassman
Glass Gars Guns Garden
Haha, shiiiit. You think you're so funny.
My limited experience would suggest Bolivar. But I wonder if partagas is up there. One would think Cohiba and Trinidad, but it doesn't really sound like it from what I've heard/read.
Seems like @SurpriseMVP @icehog3 @boltman and @Jfire might have good input. And @Master Shake if he can keep from getting salty about it.
icehog3
Outlaw Hockey Biker
Consistency is NOT Cuba's middle name. I find inconsistencies in every marca, and more luck finding consistency within a vitola than within a brand as a whole.
That being said, if hard pressed my first thought is H. Upmann.
That being said, if hard pressed my first thought is H. Upmann.
I have found the Monte #4 to be consistently good in my limited experience. Pretty much my go to cigar when I don't know what to smoke.
Nacho Daddy
Irrepressibly Irreverent Inveterate Ignominy
- Joined
- Jul 17, 2009
- Messages
- 3,479
love them dearly.
does not change a thing quality wise.
you need to just spend some $$$ and learn like everyone else has had to do .
Nacho Daddy
Irrepressibly Irreverent Inveterate Ignominy
- Joined
- Jul 17, 2009
- Messages
- 3,479
Glassman
Glass Gars Guns Garden
RyJ shorts have been consistent for me. I’ve bought 3 boxes over the last year and all were good.
icehog3
Outlaw Hockey Biker
I find Monte's to be terribly inconsistent. My Monte #4s pre-2015 were mostly great, my post 2015 ones have been mostly crap. And don't even get me started on Monte #2s.
Not a Hoyo fan in general, so I am the wrong one to opine on them.
ChuckMejia
The General
Glassman
Glass Gars Guns Garden
I tagged him because apparently he has a lot of experience with them...You should show @Jfire your vast documentation of Habanos issues
But that statement is absurd.
You don't have to have smoked many at all to know that is ridiculous.
They vary vastly in flavor, density, color, and probably every other factor you can think of. I love them but consistency is not their strong suit.
And before you even start, your comments over the last year in "What CC" and "CC purchase" are exhibit A. So get off it.
Exhibit B are everyone else's comments and experiences.
Your ability to word things to maximum infuriation value, yet manage not to get kicked, is truly impressive.
"I'm not touching you!"
The only one you're making look foolish is yourself.
Last edited:
ChuckMejia
The General
And there it is
Glassman
Glass Gars Guns Garden
I agree with this and add that they need a couple months to settle down from shipping to even have a chance to be consistent. A few years rest really helps with consistency also.
One more vote for Upmann being consistently good.