Post your Top 5 of 2009.

[CbusDave]

1. Padron 45th
2. CAO La Traviata
3. Oliva Serie V Maduro
4. Tatuaje Drac
5. CAO Lx2 Toro

 

[Jetexas]

1 Cohiba DC LE 2003, Jeffs herf last summer with excellent company
2 Partagas Lusitania Bo's Cigar Lounge Super Bowl Party with some work buddies
3 L'Esprit Robusto, gifted in person by Pete at the Beach Herf - Excellent
4 Montecristo #2 Thanksgiving with my father in-law
5 Boris on my back patio solo, with 0 interruptions

Rookie of the year, has to be the Boris!!

 

[ctaylor]

5. LP T52
4. AF Anejo
3. Tat T110
2. LFD Salomon
1. 45th maddy

Tough list this year.. a lot of good sticks

 

[hdroadglide]

from o9
cohiba gran reserva
viaje 5050
af 858 rosado
johnnyo diademas
boris

 

[birdperk]

1. PSD4
2. Opus..thanks AJ
3. SC La Punta
4. Cabaiguan Guapos Jr. maduro
5. Oliva series V

 

[scottYDucati]

Nobodys mentioned the AVO Companero? Was it not that great? My list would be but in no particular order...
Boris
El Centurion
Bolivar Royal Corona cc
PSD no. 4 cc
Opus x no. 4…three yrs old
I have high hopes for the Companero and T110 I've got coming in to determine the ROY.

 

[ctaylor]

Nobodys mentioned the AVO Companero? Was it not that great?

I forget about the Companero, prob because I have just 2 left. Its been a while since I have had one but def in my top 10

What is the Johnnyo? I would guess something from John Oliva?

 

[Jfire]

Since I smoked the Cohiba GR yesterday it will not count.
1. Tat Sw Maddie
2. SP Beli 02 (thanks Aaron)
3. Tat Cohete
4. Cohiba 5 Maddie Genios (these were horrible at the beginning of the year and turned into something phenomenal.)
5. Tat Noella Res 06 OR
New guy award:
Liga T 52 was pretty good. And this years Anejo 46s are great as well.
Failed new guy stickfor me)
Flying Pig.

 

[Clint]

Um...What's the point to have a "top 5 of 2009" if you can include any year you want?!

 

[Alwayslit]

Um...What's the point to have a "top 5 of 2009" if you can include any year you want?!

.....sort of thinking the same thing. I've had some out of this world cigars in 2009 that had nothing to do with 2009 production

 

[diesel]

Um...What's the point to have a "top 5 of 2009" if you can include any year you want?!

I assume the name of the thread may have been a bit misleading but it is simply a thread about the top 5 cigars that you smoked last year. Cigars that (in your opinion) you enjoyed most in 2009.

The point is that it is fun to reflect on the smokes that you enjoyed and it could possibly inform other BOTLs of what may be smoking good.

Though it is possible to complicate it, the thread is not meant to be taken so seriously.