this round is full. If there is enough interest I will do a second round
So I did this last fall, and 3/5 King has inspired me to do it again.
I am looking for 3 or 4 willing participants to participate in a 30 day blind review. Before you sign up, please make sure you can review 3 cigars before October 15th.
I am offering free cigars to willing participants. These will be randomly chosen by my wife out of the humidor, so they could really be just about anything. The bands will be removed, and replaced with home-made ones (something like "A1" and "C6", etc). You review them, I reveal them. Simple enough?
The emphasis on this thread is not to correctly guess what you are smoking (though you absolutely can). The emphasis is an honest review. What you liked, what you didn't like, would you want more, etc. You do not have to become halfwheel and tell us about the butter popcorn you get by sniffing the burnt ash. It must include at least one or two pictures, and should include some description as best you can.
Review will be posted on BOTL under the Domestic Cigar or CC review thread, depending on what you end up smoking.
Rules
1. Minimum 3 months active on board.
2. Minimum 2 Trader Rating
3. You must post at least one review per week per cigar. So, if I send you 3 cigars... you have 3 weeks to complete the reviews. If you don't think that you can stick to that, don't sign up
4. If you do not complete the reviews by October 15th, a negative TR will be left. Sorry to do this, but last time someone just took the cigars and took off.
Outgoing: Problemsolverjc
1. KK33
2. Hoshy
3. Smoqman
4. Rasshat
5. Stogie
6. Dtgw
Sign ups are now open. Packages will ship on Thursday assuming we get 4 signed up.
So I did this last fall, and 3/5 King has inspired me to do it again.
I am looking for 3 or 4 willing participants to participate in a 30 day blind review. Before you sign up, please make sure you can review 3 cigars before October 15th.
I am offering free cigars to willing participants. These will be randomly chosen by my wife out of the humidor, so they could really be just about anything. The bands will be removed, and replaced with home-made ones (something like "A1" and "C6", etc). You review them, I reveal them. Simple enough?
The emphasis on this thread is not to correctly guess what you are smoking (though you absolutely can). The emphasis is an honest review. What you liked, what you didn't like, would you want more, etc. You do not have to become halfwheel and tell us about the butter popcorn you get by sniffing the burnt ash. It must include at least one or two pictures, and should include some description as best you can.
Review will be posted on BOTL under the Domestic Cigar or CC review thread, depending on what you end up smoking.
Rules
1. Minimum 3 months active on board.
2. Minimum 2 Trader Rating
3. You must post at least one review per week per cigar. So, if I send you 3 cigars... you have 3 weeks to complete the reviews. If you don't think that you can stick to that, don't sign up
4. If you do not complete the reviews by October 15th, a negative TR will be left. Sorry to do this, but last time someone just took the cigars and took off.
Outgoing: Problemsolverjc
1. KK33
2. Hoshy
3. Smoqman
4. Rasshat
5. Stogie
6. Dtgw
Sign ups are now open. Packages will ship on Thursday assuming we get 4 signed up.
Last edited:
