The First 6 of Eddie Ortega's Wild Bunch

[Kip]

Since several have posted up Ortega reviews recently, thought I'd throw a couple out there. This is from my blog, but since I do it just for fun and as a hobby I'm not particularly concerned about baiting in traffic...so I'm posting the whole thing here. Just as a warning, though - it's friggin' long, because it covers 6 cigars, and I couldn't embed the pictures - so the formatting may appear "off". In fact, the forum limited the characters available, so I'll post 3 and 3. This is a "Cigar Spotlight" rather than a single-stick review....


Little over a year ago, Eddie Ortega left EOBrands and launched Ortega Cigars to a very favorable reception. I reviewed his Serie D Maduro #10 in April 2012. Subsequently, he announced the creation of a series of limited production cigars to be known as the Dirty Dozen – which would eventually be renamed the Wild Bunch. Eddie describes the project as somewhat of an homage to various people within the cigar world he has encountered that are just a little outside the box for a variety of reasons. The series is being released monthly throughout 2013 – one cigar in tribute to each of these folks. I recently had the opportunity to hang out with him at an event in Tampa, and from all appearances this project is something he is having an absolute blast doing. It is an exciting diversion for him, which he is relishing greatly. He wanted to produce a series that pays tribute to some fun people he's come to know over the years, and do it in a way that was fun for him – for those honored – and for the consumer. Each is limited to 500 boxes, with a final release in December that will include one (possibly two) from each vitola. Every cigar in the series will be a unique creation in vitola and blend; no two will be alike, and will feature some not-often-seen blend components. Additionally, quarterly samplers featuring each cigar from the included months will be available. Each vitola in the series retails for approximately $10, and will be available at Ortega’s authorized retailers. I have purchased cigars from the first three monthly releases, and Eddie was kind enough to provide additional samples as well (particularly the second quarter cigars). So, without further prattling from me, here they are:

January – Big Bad John, “The Jackhammer” (6.875X60)

Wrapper: Nicaraguan Habano Rosado
Binder: Undisclosed
Filler: Undisclosed

At nearly 7 inches and a 60 ring, the Big Bad John is well outside the normal size I would personally reach for. But, in the name of research I decided to give it a try. The first thing I noticed, besides its size, is how extremely oily the wrapper is. It is uniformly medium brown in color, and carries a remarkable sheen which is quite supple to the touch. Prelight, the aroma on the wrapper is faint, while that at the foot is a bit more bold – giving off an interesting sweetbread note. The cold draw is straightforward tobacco, with a bit of a hay flavor on the back end.

At first light and continuing through the first inch, the initial draws are very peppery, intermingled with a bright cedar flavor. While the pepper-spice will fade as the smoke progressed, it was always present throughout the length of the Big Bad John. Progressing into the second inch and into the midpoint, a backdrop of ever-so-slightly sweet leather pushes through and complements the spice nicely. Onward toward the end of the cigar, the strength picks up a bit, although I’d still put the BBJ firmly into the medium range. I find the interplay between the leather, black pepper, and (occasional) cedar to be fascinating. Captivating, even.

While I don’t typically find myself on the hunt for large ring cigars, I have to eat a little crow here and say I thoroughly enjoyed both Big Bad John examples I’ve now smoked. The pleasant flavors, great construction, and attention to blending overcame my normal aversion – which is merely a size preference. If I were to find myself in the mood for something in a 60 ring, I’d definitely consider the BBJ a prime candidate. I believe I’ll put a few down before they’re all gone for just such an occasion…

February – Iron Mike, “I-Beam” (4.875″X54)

Wrapper: Nicaraguan Habano Oscuro
Binder: Nicaraguan
Filler: Nicaraguan

The Iron Mike “I-Beam” was February’s Wild Bunch offering. Each of the three I’ve had were well built, and have sported a deeply chocolate-colored and quite toothy wrapper. Before first light, the wrapper aroma is faint to me – giving just straightforward, tobacco goodness. The foot is slightly more bold with some haylike or mild barnyard notes as well. The draw is dark and earthy, retaining some of the hay detected at the foot.

In the initial puffs, the I-Beam produces a healthy dose of “Pepin” spice; fairly peppery on the rear soft palate. I get a little bit of tannic tea flavor here as well – akin to the finish from an Irish Breakfast Tea, if you’re familiar – almost metallic – but not quite. Of the first quarter’s offerings, I find the Iron Mike most “My Father-esque” in flavor. By the time I get an inch into the smoke, these “brighter” flavors have given way to some woodsy undertones – oak, perhaps, but not charred – just undried oak wood. At about the halfway point, the profile changes once again. I pick up on some fruity sweetness on occasion, braced by a foundation of earthy pepper flavors.

The Iron Mike is absolutely one of the more complex of the first six Wild Bunch releases, and one I would imagine to do well if it ever were to be released into regular production (which isn’t going to happen, per Eddie O).

March – Island Jim, “Wahoo” (6.5″X52)

Wrapper: Ecuadoran Habano Rosado
Binder: Nicaraguan
Filler: Nicaraguan

I have probably smoked more of the Island Jim than any other Wild Bunch release to date. It has struck a chord with my palate that I have enjoyed considerably, so I’ve bought a number of them since their recent release. As a general rule, I tend to enjoy Ecuadoran-wrapped Nicaraguan blends, and this is no exception. A quick look over the Island Jim shows a continuing trend with Ortega’s cigars in showing impeccable construction, providing a flawless cap and wrapper application, and neither discernible voids nor overly dense areas. Prelight, the draw is deliberate but free, and has a thick, grain-reminiscent flavor.

The initial puffs provide an edgy, dry spice that gets one’s attention but is tempered by the oat and grain flavor mentioned in the prelight draw. This has receded considerably by the end of the first inch, however, and the grain has mellowed – developing a bit of a malted character at this point. Throughout the midsection of the Island Jim, I get a fair amount of the tangy sweetness I occasionally find in Nicaraguan tobacco, and an increasing tingle in the nose from some peppery spice that begins to build.

By the final portion, this spice has picked up considerably, although never overpowering in effect. I have had near perfect burn in each Island Jim so far, with even minor retouches being few and far between. After “Tony the Boss”, this is probably my favorite of the as-yet released Wild Bunch.

 

[Kip]

April – Tony, “The Boss” (7.5″X49)

Wrapper: Ecuadoran Habano Rosado
Binder: Undisclosed
Filler: Nicaraguan and Mexican

I first had the opportunity to try an early prerelease sample of Tony the Boss back in November, when I happened to run into Eddie at Charmed Leaf down in Delray Beach. Despite the fact that Eddie told me it was very fresh off the table, I found it to be an incredible smoke that I knew I would enjoy as frequently as possible once it hit the shelf. The sample I received from him and smoked for this review proved that theory to be well founded.

Before lighting, “The Boss” has a mild aroma at both the foot and wrapper. The wrapper is the more bold of the two, giving off a hint of cedar. Otherwise, the only noticeable aroma is that of tobacco. The draw is deliberate, but well within normal range. The cold draw does provide a bit of a sweet oat flavor, but like the aroma is very mild.

I’m greeting with some spice at first light, but not overpoweringly so. This is somewhat different from my experience in November, although not markedly. I don’t remember much pepper at all at the time, although my memory is certainly subject to outright failure at times. I get some black pepper throughout the first inch of “The Boss,”with a backdrop of some sweetness – tropical spices, with just the slightest hint of brown sugar or graham cracker even. These sweet flavors develop more in the middle portion of “The Boss,” and boldly take the helm by the halfway mark.

By the final stretch of “The Boss,” the toasty sweetness mentioned above has progressed nicely, and the cigar has settled firmly in the medium-strength range for me. The early spice has subsided considerably, but still pushes through on occasion – and, in fact, presented clearly in the very end. Tony “The Boss” is possibly my favorite of the first six vitolas of the Wild Bunch, followed by “Honest Abe” and “Island Jim.” I have already begun the process of clearing space to store some for the days to come when they’re no longer available…

May – Dandy McCoy, “Empire State” (6″X54)

Wrapper: Connecticut Broadleaf
Binder: Undisclosed
Filler: Nicaraguan/Mexican/Honduran

Next up is the Dandy McCoy “Empire State,” which is listed as 6″X54. I did not measure the ring, but the press on this cigar gives it a somewhat smaller profile – if it’s a 54 ring, it would have to be the longer of the two rectangular dimensions. The “short side” is clearly narrower than that. Unexpectedly, the wrapper and foot aroma are similar to the Iron Mike – although, with a bit more “pep.” It actually drew a sneeze from me when giving the foot a cursory sniff. The draw on the one smoked for today was the most open of all the Wild Bunch Series I’ve tried, but still well within normal acceptable range. The prelight flavors on the draw were dark and earthy, and actually less sweet than I would have imagined beforehand. I guess I sometimes expect a bit more sweetness with both CT Broadleaf and Mexican tobaccos (although certainly not always in Mexican leaf, depending on a number of factors). It just goes to show preconceptions can be very misleading. What I do get in the first third of the Dandy McCoy is a bounty of nasal spice. The spice is neither tasted nor perceived on the palate so much as felt in the nose upon retrohale. The flavors are predominantly toasty to me, like a slightly charred marshmallow, only less sweet. I did notice the ash fell much quicker on this stick than the others, at only about 1/2″. These early flavors are unfamiliar to me, in that I typically think of toasted flavors as being dark and savory; or more “relaxed.” The toastiness in this cigar presents itself as a more frenetic, alkaline accompaniment. This is definitely one of the more unique cigars in the line to date. With the others in the series, I could think of something…somewhere….sometime that at the very least reminded me of the same experience. The Dandy McCoy is very unique in character, and not extremely similar to anything that came to mind from my smoking past. The spice subsided considerably by the midpoint of the cigar, and was replaced by a slight hint of citrus twang. Not directly citrus per se, just a hint of tartness. The strength is a bit sneaky…it never “seems” like a potent cigar, but will give you the velvet hammer treatment if you’re not carefully minding your cadence. Overall, the toasty breadiness was prevalent throughout for me. This was the theme for the entire length of the cigar, with occasional diversions into the lighter, brighter flavor families. I have only had the opportunity to smoke one example of “Empire State,” though; I think more experimentation is called for….

June – Honest Abe, “Ringmaster” (6.5″X52)

Wrapper: Undisclosed
Binder: Nicaraguan
Filler: Nicaraguan

Along with the “Island Jim”, the “Honest Abe” is also clear concerning for whom it takes its name. “Honest Abe” is Abe Dababneh, owner of the Smoke Inn chain of tobacconists in South Florida (“Island Jim” is Jim Robinson, owner of Leaf and Bean in the Strip, Pittsburgh, PA). I could find no information on the wrapper for this vitola, but if has a dry feel to it, is moderately veiny, and evenly colored a medium brown with just the very slightest red tint to it. The wrapper doesn’t release much in the way of aroma before lighting, although the foot is very leathery and sweet. Construction, again, is flawlessly executed in this line. The cold draw is mild in flavor, with hints of sweet hay.

The initial puffs of the “Honest Abe” are at an incredible fervor. The spice on the soft palate and through the nose is intense to say the least. I’m talkin’ full-on, eye-waterin’ jalapeño style. I’m not normally an extreme pepper fiend, but decided I would stick with this cigar because the accompanying flavors were so interesting. I’m glad I did. The spice subsided within the next few minutes, which really brought the Abe into its prime. The pepper didn’t go away – it just came back to a more comfortable level for my tastes. The flavors that began to present themselves were quite entertaining – some caramel with a bit of tartness to it….almost like a butterscotch. Just an inkling of café con leche. Myriad bits of goodness.

As I continued into the “Honest Abe,” I took a minute to look it over more closely in terms of construction, as I tend to do. I believe this cigar is the most expertly crafted stick of all the examples I’ve smoked from the Wild Bunch. The seams are almost indiscernible, the cap well applied, draught perfect for my preference, and the burn impeccable. Simply a glowing example of the torcedor’s craft. Nearing the halfway point, I notice that the early spice has now considerably faded. The peppery flavor is still present, but the nasal burn has all but dissipated. The earlier noted flavors are still predominant. Although certainly not a dead match, this cigar reminds me of the most recent My Father Limited Edition blend. The retention of the black pepper flavor, coupled with a developing presentation of cream creates a unique and quite pleasant experience.


The flavors begin to “darken” as progress is made into the final portion of the “Honest Abe.” More leathery, perhaps; almost a sweetened coffee – but less sweet than earlier noted. It begins to lean toward a more earthy profile, but this never really builds to a dominant characteristic of the cigar. The sweet yet spicy interplay of the flavors that I’ve found so entertaining throughout this stick continue on to the very end. Now, on the final of the first six issues of the Wild Bunch, I believe I will take back something I wrote earlier: I think the “Honest Abe” is the most “My Father-esque” cigar of the first six. This one has Garcia written all over it. Being a fan of many other My Father-produced cigars, I’m loving it.

Eddie Ortega was very ambitious in taking on this project. In my eyes, he has done a superb job with the blending for each of these first six cigars – there is something in the mix for every smoker. Sweet, spicy, bold, rich, subtle, medium, full….you name it. There is a cigar – or half dozen – you will enjoy. I am very much looking forward to the remaining releases in the Wild Bunch. No fewer than three of these first six will be stashed away in my humidor to experiment with as time marches on.

 

[Alwayslit]

Nice review

 

[38-50]

Very nice work, thanks for the reviews. Looking forward to trying a few of these.

 

[Zedman05]

Thanks Kip. That must have taken you hours to type out haha.

 

[MattSRoss81]

Hey Kip - didn't realize you made your way over to BOTL! Welcome!

Great reviews - thank you! Intriguingly, I've heard mixed reviews about most of the Wild Bunch.

 

[Kip]

I think there's something for just about anybody in the Wild Bunch - depending on tastes and preferences of course. I'm not a fan of big rings, so the Big Bad John just isn't my style - I think the blend is there; I just don't go for cigars in that format. Island Jim, Honest Abe, and Iron Mike are definite frontrunners for me at the halfway point....