I've got v cutters, Xikar, Palio, scissors, and punches... all of them.
And let me tell you, I use them all. It depends on what I am smoking or doing... sometimes I punch or vcut, esp if it is one of the better sticks with mixed size filler. If I feel more like the cigar "ritual", I grab the scissors and take my time giving the little guy a haircut. But, if I am just going out to smoke... then I grab the palio and call it good. I have been using my Xikar almost exclusively since I got it (off fleabay, and cheap too) they are a great cutter.
BUT - once I recently purchased a palio, though, it all changed. It took some getting used to because the actions and feel in your hand are different between palio and xikar, but for me, the Palio has just been a cut above... heh heh.
Go to a shop with both and put them in your hands. That will help you decide.... find a brother who will let you use his on a stick next time you smoke together... nothing qrong with a test drive.