What's new
  • BOTL UPCOMING MAINTENANCE

    Hi Everyone, as mentioned in my introduction post, BOTL needs quite a bit of updating, patching and whatever else I might come across. Over time BOTL may be unreachable on occasion as I do migrations or updates, etc. Just be patient - we'll be back! I'll generally try to keep these maintenances until later in the evenings.

Does Price Determine Quality for Cigars?

blessednxs65

Is it Nicaraguan
Rating - 100%
33   0   0
Joined
Aug 13, 2007
Messages
2,933
Location
Tracy, CA
By Cameron Elliott

One the biggest mysteries is what separates a cheap cigar from an expensive one, and if that relates to differentiating a bad cigar from a good one. Part of the answer is that good cigars use higher quality tobacco and better blends of tobacco. Good cigars are hand rolled instead of machine made. But there's more to it than that.

Whenever I buy cigars, I'm intimated by the vast array of smokes before me. Admittedly, I am indecisive. Too many choices is paralyzing. As a connoisseur, I'm drawn to quality: I want to enjoy my cigar. But, also, I'm trying to save money; is the extra money worth it? Will I really be able to tell the difference? Granted, expensive doesn't automatically mean better, but with things like cigars and wine, you generally get what you pay for.

As a rule, higher priced cigars are of higher quality. But they might be overpriced. I'd love to spend less, but when things are too cheap, I begin to worry. Like when you go to gas stations and find burritos for only 69 cents. It kind of creeps me out. Why isn't it more? What corners have been cut to bring me this tasty burrito for such a low price? Similarly: what fabulous rare and fresh ingredients have been put into it if it's a five dollar variety?

This is when I realize I've been standing there too long. I love the wonderful and delicious aroma of walk- in humidors, but it is slightly intoxicating. Spend too much time in one, and you begin to wonder what corners have been cut to give you such a good smoke at such a low price.

And the reality is, probably some corners have been cut, albeit some corners are cut more gracefully than others. The reason good cigars cost more is because they're aged longer. A quality wrapper might be aged 7 and half years before the cigar is even rolled. Then, the rolled cigar is put in a cedar room an aged for 90 days or more.

This two- step aging process mellows out the flavor of the tobacco. A cigar might be made using leaves from 20 plants, and aging marries the different types of leaves, creating harmony between each one. The different leaves blend together and create a complex flavor.

So the great mystery has finally been solved. There are certainly other factors involved, but a good cigar is one that has been properly aged. The next time you find yourself in an intoxicating humidor with a plethora of cigars, have faith in your decision. I'm no capitalist, but go ahead and spend those extra 3 or 4 dollars and buy a quality cigar, one that has been aged and made with love. It will be worth it.
 
Rating - 100%
206   0   0
Joined
Dec 12, 2004
Messages
6,454
Location
Idaho
I don't agree with Mr Elliott's last paragraph. While aging of the tobacco and the cigar is certainly is one factor in determining a "good cigar" and it's price, IMO, there are several other key factors involved ...

Experience of the rollers
Quality of the tobacco
Makeup of the blend
Demand + supply chain
Brand name
Your own palate

I've smoked more than my share of crappy $10 cigars and enough fantastic $3 ones to know that it takes a whole village to raise a "good cigar".
 

oneaday

2007 BoY
Rating - 100%
112   0   0
Joined
Dec 18, 2004
Messages
2,944
Location
Sonoran Desert
I don't agree with Mr Elliott's last paragraph. While aging of the tobacco and the cigar is certainly is one factor in determining a "good cigar" and it's price, IMO, there are several other key factors involved ...

Experience of the rollers
Quality of the tobacco
Makeup of the blend
Demand + supply chain
Brand name
Your own palate

I've smoked more than my share of crappy $10 cigars and enough fantastic $3 ones to know that it takes a whole village to raise a "good cigar".
Ted is spot on here.

If price were the only factor everyone would agree the LE production cigars would be near the top of everyone's short list. I don't believe that to be the case, certainly not for me. LE pricing is based on hype/demand and supply with few exceptions they have fallen short of the mark for me and most I know. The LE productions are just one example where price falls short of quality. Anyone remember the cigar boom years?
 

Fox

BoM May '07
Rating - 100%
70   0   0
Joined
Dec 21, 2005
Messages
1,827
Location
Northwest
Ted is spot on here.

If price were the only factor everyone would agree the LE production cigars would be near the top of everyone's short list. I don't believe that to be the case, certinly not for me. LE pricing is based on hype/demand and supply with few exceptions they have fallen short of the mark for me and most I know. The LE productions are just one example where price falls short of quality. Anyone remember the cigar boom years?
The LE is a great example.
 

BradMc

<b>Charity Liaison</b><br>BoM September 07
Rating - 100%
148   0   0
Joined
Dec 18, 2005
Messages
9,028
Location
Aiken SC
I don't agree with Mr Elliott's last paragraph. While aging of the tobacco and the cigar is certainly is one factor in determining a "good cigar" and it's price, IMO, there are several other key factors involved ...

Experience of the rollers
Quality of the tobacco
Makeup of the blend
Demand + supply chain
Brand name
Your own palate
CWS Question: Does Price Determine Quality for Cigars?
Answer: No.
These 2 have said it ALL.........
 

Jwrussell

April '05 BoM
Rating - 100%
105   0   0
Joined
Dec 12, 2004
Messages
9,828
Location
Tampa, FL
He is also talking about NC cigars based on his descriptions. The Cubans have just started to get into aging tobacco for longer periods of time, IIRC.
 
Top