Going for a first box....

[JMN]

Oliva would be a great first box to keep around. My first was actually a Oliva G Toro box.

 

[nickb218]

CAO Criollo Pato is an awesome smoke that never disappoints and the same goes for the short story..

 

[Smurf]

It looks like the vote is leading to the SS, with the Oliva in close second.

No support for the RP Vintage.

I will let it ferment in my head for a bit, maybe buy a couple more singles of each, and then decide.... but the brothers say Short Story.

 

[Halon]

RP vintages are awesome, too! I have a couple boxes of those. But yeah, for short smokes, it's hard to beat the Short Story. I like the little Brazilias the best, tho.
Either way, you can't go wrong with any of the mentioned boxes! You could also maybe get two or three boxes total, and do a box split on here, where you sell off a couple fivers from each box. That way you get a decent amount of a few different cigars without having to pay for multiple boxes.


TYLER