Still pretty new to pipes so here's mine from what I've tried. C&D Haunted Bookshop, Scotty's Trout stream, & , don't laugh I know it's cheap but I like it, Carter Hall. The pipe would have to be a MM cob of some sort.
PS luxury twist flake- great burn, easy on the palate, crowd pleaser.
SG St. James flake- so many good VaPer flakes/coins out there, SJF is my pick if I was cracking tins ROTT.
Balkan Sobranie- hard to find but a tin or two is all I'd need.
What he ^^^^ said- SMS Meerschaum would be my pipe.