Speaking from my experience, take that for whatever it is worth, I have been buying quality boxes of cigars from CI for years. Never had a sub prime box, ever. Now I have bought off brand, seconds and x outs that were advertised as such. I quit buying close outs becuse the writers at CI are very good at making a cigar sound good. Most are not. The seconds I bought, RP's, Perdomo, Indian Tabac were always excellent sticks at great prices. A blemish here a spot there, yes. But as advertised.
I found with CI like any bulk seller I had to know my cigars and buy what I knew. Good, price, great people.
Sorry Zen, I dont buy it.