Depends who you ask. If you ask my wife, she'll roll her eyes and say "It's just insane how many cigars he has." If you ask me ... well, okay I'll admit I have too many cigars, lol.
considering the number of people who order their cigar bands in 1,000 increments (or the guy Bob said ordered 6,000...), my guess is there are those who keep plenty more than 500.
I'm probably around 300 myself. Which at my smoking rate is definitely more than a year's supply...