I've said this before - but this is just a reminder. I'll be breaking BOTL over time in order to get it into a far better place. Just be patient if you can't reach us! We'll be back
Looks like you have your bases covered with mild, med and full bodied cigars. I wouldn't over think it, you said it yourself most of these people are novices.
Sounds like a good time to me.
I was thinking:
Warped Villa Sombra Mojito
Perdomo Champagne Corona Extra
Arturo Fuente Short Story
Undercrown Maduro Corona Viva or Sun Grown Corona
Oliva V / V Melanio / V Melanio Maduro
Foundation El Gueguense Corona Gorda
MF Le Bijou 1922 / MF The Judge
Liga Privada No. 9 / T52
And if you're going super high end, maybe some FF Opus X, Padron 1926 (don't have to go with the 90th) and 1964.