Preference: Punch vs Hoyo Rothschild double maduro?

[hoser45]

Any opinions on how these two double maduro, or oscuro, sticks compare in flavor and quality?

 

[Zen Cigar Man]

Its funny you ask. Rumor is for a long time these two lines were similar (if not the same) blends.

 

[hoser45]

Are Punch and HDM owned by the same company?

 

[wideboy]

I have not had the HDM, but the Punch Double Maduro was one of my first favorites

 

[tatuaje]

Its funny you ask. Rumor is for a long time these two lines were similar (if not the same) blends.

Bingo

 

[hoser45]

Bingo

Bingo...it's the same exact blend...
or Bingo...rumor is it's the same exact blend?

 

[tatuaje]

Bingo...it's the same exact blend...
or Bingo...rumor is it's the same exact blend?

Sorry agreeing with the rumor...I can't confirm but I always thought they were the same cigar....

 

[NorcalMark]

Sorry agreeing with the rumor...I can't confirm but I always thought they were the same cigar....

I always thought they were the same cigar as well.