So you're on a deserted island....

[The_Rev]

Here's the question: you get banished to a deserted island and you can choose a lifetime supply of one pipe tobacco. Pick the one.

 

[Griz]

Boswell's northwoods

 

[mikeman84]

That's a tough one, I think I would go with Mississippi river.

 

[redneck_toy]

Granted, I've only been piping a few weeks, but right now it'd have to be Frog Morton on the Bayou

 

[The_Rev]

I'm torn between Dunhill Flake and my B&M's (Crescent City Cigar Shop) house blend, Goedewaagen. I love both products. I'm going with Goedewaagen.

 

[atbat82]

Man...that's a tough call. Based on what I've smoked so far, it would either be Northwoods or Frog Morton Cellar.

 

[mdwest]

whichever one is most positively buoyant and is most durable when used to fill an improvised flotation device...

fuck being stranded on a deserted island... there are no cigars there!

 

[oside]

crystallized full virginia flake

 

[Hoshneer]

I am gonna go with Frog Morton on the Bayou as well.

 

[BrewinHooligan]

Granted I haven't gone through as many blends as most but for me at this moment it would be MS River.

 

[CVAC085]

Torn between something from the Frog Morton or Boswell's....so something from eitjer of them works lol.

 

[StogieNinja]

: enters thread :

: realizes it's a piper thread :

: slowly backs out :

 

[Agentskull]

: enters thread :

: realizes it's a piper thread :

: slowly backs out :

So you're curious. On the fence. Just need that push...

 

[StogieNinja]

So you're curious. On the fence. Just need that push...

lol, no. No, no, no.

II have seven pipes, all of which are very nice, including a Peterson, Savinelli, Nording, and a few cobs, most of which I don't smoke, two of which have never been smoked. I probably have several pounds of tobacco, including probably two dozen samples I haven't even tried yet, at least eight oz of aged Stonehaven, and at least eight tins of good aged tobacco from Dunhill, GL Pease, etc.

I say all that so no one here will think I'm in anyway needing anything related to piping. I'm good, really! I haven't gotten into it yet, but it's not for lack of supply!

 

[Agentskull]

lol, no. No, no, no.

I have seven pipes, all of which are very nice, including a Peterson, Savinelli, Nording, and a few cobs, most of which I don't smoke, two of which have never been smoked. I probably have several pounds of tobacco, including probably two dozen samples I haven't even tried yet, at least eight oz of aged Stonehaven, and at least eight tins of good aged tobacco from Dunhill, GL Pease, etc.

I say all that so no one here will think I'm in anyway needing anything related to piping. I'm good, really! I haven't gotten into it yet, but it's not for lack of supply, honestly!

Just giving you a hard time bro. No worries

 

[StogieNinja]

Just giving you a hard time bro. No worries

Word. Just wanted to make sure the pipers knew better targets were available!

 

[CVAC085]

Word. Just wanted to make sure the pipers knew better targets were available!

That's not enough baccy. A piper simply can't have such small amounts of baccy.

 

[StogieNinja]

That's not enough baccy. A piper simply can't have such small amounts of baccy.

lol, seriously dude. I'm not even into piping, and I'm really well stocked compared to some that are. I'm sure there are plenty of folks with smaller stashes that are not only much more deserving, but much more enthusiastic!

Let's get this back on track!

To answer the OP's question, I would have to say Stonehaven. I know it has it's fans and detractors, but I love the way it burns so cleanly and the flavor is fantastic.

 

[Tennessee Dave]

Stonehaven

 

[JustTroItIn]

Very tough question. I'll say some aged Hamborger Veermaster.

Watching @StogieNinja sweat is funny. You really do have to watch what you say around here.