Upmann or Hoyo..........

[JG358]

Upmann for sure.

 

[LeafBound]

I am having this very dilemma now between the Hup 46 and Hoy Ep #2, only experience is with Ep Esp.

The box plunge is scary lol. Seems to be a definitive preference of the Upmann’s here.

 

[I.T. Guy]

I am having this very dilemma now between the Hup 46 and Hoy Ep #2, only experience is with Ep Esp.

The box plunge is scary lol. Seems to be a definitive preference of the Upmann’s here.

Start with the 46’s


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Nacho Daddy]

Mag 46..

you will thank me...

 

[Jimmy_jack]

Just had a mag 46 today. God I love Upmann. If I could do it over I would have many more boxes of Upmann, across the vitolas.

Sent from my Pixel 3 XL using Tapatalk

 

[multi-useless]

I'm gonna be the oddball here and say Hoyo all day. So far, the Epi 2 has blown me away and the Palmas Extras have been a surprisingly good cheapie, where the Mag 46 was a total disappointment ROTT (and I usually enjoy a smoke ROTT), and the other Upmanns have been good but not great, save for maybe a few HUHC but even those have been inconsistent for me.

I'll guess I'll head over to my go-to vendor now, to try a few more of both...

 

[irratebass]

I'm a Hoyo whore, but I do enjoy me some Upmanns as well. My goal is to own all the offering from Hoyo.......it's not a short term goal.

 

[jvd1230]

I've never had Hoyo, but I know I like mag46s (got a box on hand!)so I'd have to go with upmann.

 

[TNTGOLFER]

Connie a and the B puts HU above them!

 

[Tennessee Dave]

Upmann's need about 5 years of age before they reach their peak in my opinion. It's well worth the effort. One of the best out there.

 

[Altercall]

I’ve got ‘99 Short Hoyo Coronas and ‘00 Hoyo Churchill’s that are amazing. I’ll take Hoyo!!!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[BasicTek]

I like my Hoyo Palmas better than the similar Upman Regalias but I like the Upman Mag 46 better than my Hoyo EP#2. Honestly though I like selection so I'd probably split.

 

[Opie]

Can I change my answer?

 

[multi-useless]

Can I change my answer?

What did you smoke that changed your mind?

 

[CigarGavin]

Upmann 100%

Fresh-2 years: Mangum 50’s (2015-2017 where stupid good fresh)

2 years-5 years: Connie A’s and No.2

5 years-8 years: Connie No. 1 and Half Coronas (to be fair the 2013-2014 Half Coronas took FOREVER to get good and the new-er years are great faster)

8 years-and up: Magnum 46 and sir winnies (I’m not sure there is a better cigar than an aged mag 46)

All that being said a HDM epicure deluxe with a few years is almost as rich as a well blended Upmann and deserves some credit

Obviously all subjective and IMHO aka worthless lol


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Opie]

What did you smoke that changed your mind?

Just learning to appreciate the milder end of the spectrum I guess. San Juan is probably the one that made me re visit the line.

 

[Unpossible_1]

Just learning to appreciate the milder end of the spectrum I guess. San Juan is probably the one that made me re visit the line.

#bombOpieHdM

 

[Alwayslit]

If I had to be forced then Upmann. I do enjoy the Hoyo DD's

 

[IceClass]

I'm a total Hoyo whore.

 

[jwintosh]

Definitely an upmann fan. Connie 1 is my favorite go-to. Never disappoints. And the Sir Winnie can be magical. As for HdM, I haven’t had one that was memorable.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk