I admit, usually going to the B&M on a whim I'll usually get a stick I haven't heard of or tried typically based on ring size, shape, and color. I know, all of those characteristics don't influence the sheer taste of a cigar. Its just my comfort zone, and I like it there. With that being said, I like 50 or larger ring gage, belicoso shape, and super oscuro to ligero.
Its kind of freaks me out to see the greenish colored cigars, and knowing that some people dye the maduro color.
However, I like all cigars. I'll smoke just about anyone of them, regardless of shape, size, or color.