#9 vs. Undercrown vs. T52

[Clint]

So which is your favorite?

 

[njstone]

I have not yet had an Undercrown.

Fresh, the winner is the T52 for me, hands down.

Aged (18-months or more), and it's a real close call between the T52 and the #9 for me.

My favorite LP overall has been the #9 Flying Pig.

 

[PatrickL]

I'd like to vote for the Dirty Rat. I'd smoke that over the other three in a heartbeat.

 

[TommyGunz]

I'd like to vote for the Dirty Rat. I'd smoke that over the other three in a heartbeat.

x2 perfect size

 

[bugbear]

LP No 9 Toro
LP T52 Flying Pig
LP Unico Dirty Rat

Three way tie. Also agree with the age comment. NUM NUM NUM

 

[ciggy]

Haha...guess I'm the only one so far. I like the Undercrown the best!
I like the other two but I just feel the Undercrown flavors shine over it's strength.

 

[UTvols186]

I am going to have to say the #9. I agree that the #9 Flying Pig is by far the best

 

[TreeFrog Frank]

This is really tough.

First knee-jerk reaction, I thought T52.... Been a while since I've had a 9, but when I have, it was a little aged, and it was good. And the Undercrown is different on so many levels... Man... what to choose...

 

[hdroadglide]

1. dirty rat
1 1/2. t 52
1 3/4. aged #9

 

[danthebugman]

That's a tough call. They're all three very good cigars...Dirty Rat included, but then you'd probably have to toss the L40 up there too if you did that. It just depends on what kind of mood I'm in, but since trying the Undercrown I've liked that one the best. I have had some issues keeping a few lit after about half way in, but overall flavors rock and quality is very good. Price is a few bucks less than the others too so that helps some.

Dan

 

[FireDoc83]

I enjoy all of them... Initially I was saying the T52 because I am hoarding (Oops I mean aging) a couple boxes in my humi. But I am on an Undercrown kick right now so that is my vote. But you gotta love the No9.

 

[CigarSaint]

T52, Undercrown, then #9

 

[Clint]

I knew there would be many votes/comments on the Pig, Rat, et al....I wanted to poll the reg production cigars and/or non limited production sticks.:thumbsup:

 

[jsnake]

Smoked the Undercrown last night and it was amazing. It has been a while since a cigar was WOW for me. I loved everything about it and am definitely getting more. If you haven't had one yet you really need to get some. Not just one but some because they are great.

 

[BradMc]

T-52 = #1
# 9 = # 2
Undercrown =#3

 

[podman28]

I am a T-52 guy but would never turn down any of them.

 

[jerseyjay]

LP No9 Toro hands down !

 

[drob03]

1. Undercrown
2. LP #9
3. LP T52


All three are great smokes.

 

[Jadawin]

I really like all 3, but I smoke the T52 the most (may change with Undercrown now being available...)

 

[MReschke0626]

1. T52
2. Undercrown
3. No. 9

The T52 is just that rustic, full-bodied blend of awesomeness that while never overly fancy or gimicky, is always amazing. To me is follows the same secret of success as the Cojonu 2003. Original, rustic, amazing. I do love the Undercrown tho, and the more I try my few robustos out that I'm letting sleep a bit, the more I like them too.