#9 for me. All that cedar flavor... I much preferred it to the two T52s I've smoked.
The Feral Pig was amazing, really wish I had more of those, but they're a special occasion cigar. Way to much for a normal kind of smoking experience, it's the kind of cigar I'd want to smoke at a party, cause even with all the distractions, it would make me pay attention to it!
For me it would be:
#9
FFP
Undercrown
Dirty Rat
T52
Still haven't tried the L40, A, or the UF (can't remember the number, it was originally the JD40 I think)