BOTL Top 25 of 2018 - Voting

[Glassman]

Damn, that requires a spreadsheet fingerless-homeboi!

Ha! I thought you just did it intuitively from memory!

Good Brain challenge. Need to keep that mind sharp if you're not schoolin now Doc...

 

[Pennywise827]

I think I speak for us all when I say Im dissapointed this isnt done yet....

Its not gonna sort itself Jeremy.

 

[Glassman]

I think I speak for us all when I say Im dissapointed this isnt done yet....

Its not gonna sort itself Jeremy.

Bahaha! Thanks a lot Wes..

Btw, how are you at spreadsheets?....

 

[Pennywise827]

Bahaha! Thanks a lot Wes..

Btw, how are you at spreadsheets?....

Haha I have a girl I hired to do those...shes a wizz....Brandon and Mikey are good at em, recruit!

 

[Necron99]

If you're still taking nominees, haven't been online here much lately but figured I'd toss in my favs from this year.
1. Davidoff Colorado Claro Double R
2. Padron 1926 Series 80th Anniversary Maduro
3. Le Careme by Crowned Heads.
4. Oliva Serie V Melanio Maduro
5. CAO Brazillia Gol

 

[Glassman]

If you're still taking nominees, haven't been online here much lately but figured I'd toss in my favs from this year.
1. Davidoff Colorado Claro Double R
2. Padron 1926 Series 80th Anniversary Maduro
3. Le Careme by Crowned Heads.
4. Oliva Serie V Melanio Maduro
5. CAO Brazillia Gol

Thank you. I'd been hoping more people would speak up. The more crossover over there is, the better results we'll have.

 

[Pennywise827]

Translation:

The more folks post, the longer I put this off...lol

 

[That Carpenter Guy]

Are newbies allowed to participate? If so here are my top 5 I've smoked this year.
5. Oliva Serie G Maduro Robusto
4. Arturo Fuente 858 Maduro Corona
3. Crowned Heads Le Carema Corona
2. Avo Classic Robusto
1. Brick House Maduro Robusto

 

[CigarGavin]

2015-2016 RASS
Tatuaje Reserva Broadleaf (Unico)
2015 Trini Vigia
2017 Boli Royal Coronas
Placencia Alma del Campo (but you gotta retro or it’s just “great” not awesome)


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Smokin Devil]

Because I am pretty new, I can only give two nominations with good conscience:
1. My Father Le Bijou 1922
2, Man O War Ruination

 

[ar2381]

I haven’t smoked any new CCs this year, so here is my list:

1. Joya de Nicaragua Cinco Decadas Diadema
2. Liga Privada 10th Anniversary
3. Sin Compromiso No. 5 Parejo
4. One Off Corona Gorda
5. Padron 64 Maduro Presidente Tubo

 

[Xavier Dredo]

1. Illusione Haute 10
2. Warped Gran Reserve 1988
3. OneOff Corona Gorda
4. Illusione eccj 20th
5. Foundation Tabernacle Havana Seed
6. Curivari El Gran Rey Robusto
7. C&A Cornelius Lonsdale
8. Laranja Corona Gorda
9. My Father Le Bijou 1922 Petite Robusto
10. Crowned Heads Four Kicks Robusto (I smoke more of these than anything else and am on my second box this year, so maybe it should be my #1!)

 

[iam6884]

This was damn hard to put together.
10) Liga Privada Papas Fritas
9) Warped Guardian of the Farm Torpedo
8) Oliva V Melanio Robusto
7) RomaCraft Cromagnon Robusto
6) Eiroa Maduro Toro
5) Davidoff Nicauragua Toro
4) Caldwell Hit & Run Toro
3) Padron '64 Maduro Torpedo
2) RyJ Short Churchill
1) Aladino Corono Reserva

 

[navyvet]

So when is the list coming out

 

[Bruce T.]

Did anyone figure out a top 5 list? If not , I was thinking of doing it.

 

[Hopduro]

Did anyone figure out a top 5 list? If not , I was thinking of doing it.

Lol @Glassman is lazy

Sent from my Pixel 2 using Tapatalk

 

[Glassman]

Lol @Glassman is lazy

Sent from my Pixel 2 using Tapatalk

Gah! I've been trying to make time to do it!

Maybe Sunday....

 

[multi-useless]

Gah! I've been trying to make time to do it!

Maybe Sunday....

Jeremy, I should have my top 10 for you sometime next week

 

[Hopduro]

Gah! I've been trying to make time to do it!

Maybe Sunday....

Sent from my Pixel 2 using Tapatalk

 

[Bruce T.]

I started to compile the results yesterday. It's not what I thought. I decided to just look at the top 5 rather than the top 10 since most people didn't list 10. With just the top 5 there are OVER 230 ENTRIES! And the worst part is that they are almost all different. There are very few cigars that get more than one vote. It is very challenging to look at.

I have given people's list a weighted score of 1 to 5. Many people didn't rank their list so I gave them a score of 2 out of 5 for each. There are a couple that are out in front but most only show up once. I think I'll be able to pick the top 3 but the rest will have too low a score to be relevant. I think I may also post the most popular brands. For example Warped got lots of votes but there were all for different cigars so none have a chance to crack the top 5. Other challenges include the short forms that many people used that I have to try and figure out. Also, some of the brands that are both CC and NC are a problem. I can't always tell which H. Upman they are referring to. Anyway, I'll post my results soon.