Camacho Liberty half off sale...do they suck?

[heavyd]

Atlantic has these at half price. Wondering if they suck. Have not tried them in years..

 

[04EDGE40]

I just doubled your likes... you must've done most of your posting before the "like" system was employed

Edit: on a side note, I have no input for you as I've never tried a Liberty...

 

[Craig Mac]

I've always had a thing for the Camacho Liberty. It was one of my first box purchases back in the day and I can say now a lot of it was the presentation of the coffins in a fancy looking box. But I did honestly enjoy the cigars too.

I don't know if my tastes changed but I was a fan of the Camacho Liberty until the 2009 edition. Loved the earlier releases but didn't care for the 2009-2011 editions, they just seemed flat to me plus these cigars for some reason were prone to mold.

The 12 & 13 were much better, but I didn't care much for the 2014 hoping the 2015 will be better.

 

[ascrivner]

Yes they suck. Buy anything else.

 

[shaun341]

I did a blind review of a 14 on another forum and my final thoughts on it were pretty decent but I had thought it to be a mid range smoke price wise (over $5 under $10) so the sale must put them in the spot I thought.

 

[daleo8803]

The 2013 was a awesome stick for me. Haven't had a 2014 yet.

 

[ChiefIlliniwek]

I bought a 2014 that was on sale for around $10 a couple of weeks ago. I had been eyeballing them for awhile. I haven't smoked it yet, but I'm looking forward to it.

 

[danmdevries]

Have a 12 in the coffin but haven't yet opened it. Bought it as bombing filler, figured the presentation would probably be more impressive than the cigar.

 

[Tombstone]

Its an ok cigar but nothing to write home about.

 

[JayD]

Older ones were very good. I have not had one since 2011 though.

 

[thedismaltrade]

I've always had a thing for the Camacho Liberty. It was one of my first box purchases back in the day and I can say now a lot of it was the presentation of the coffins in a fancy looking box. But I did honestly enjoy the cigars too.

I don't know if my tastes changed but I was a fan of the Camacho Liberty until the 2009 edition. Loved the earlier releases but didn't care for the 2009-2011 editions, they just seemed flat to me plus these cigars for some reason were prone to mold.

The 12 & 13 were much better, but I didn't care much for the 2014 hoping the 2015 will be better.

This exactly.

 

[Barry2Guys]

Currently smoking the 2015, I wouldn't call it the best but its not the worst. Middle of the road.