I've always had a thing for the Camacho Liberty. It was one of my first box purchases back in the day and I can say now a lot of it was the presentation of the coffins in a fancy looking box. But I did honestly enjoy the cigars too.
I don't know if my tastes changed but I was a fan of the Camacho Liberty until the 2009 edition. Loved the earlier releases but didn't care for the 2009-2011 editions, they just seemed flat to me plus these cigars for some reason were prone to mold.
The 12 & 13 were much better, but I didn't care much for the 2014 hoping the 2015 will be better.