As a resident of the east side of indy I will tell you Blend is by far the best around. Very very nice place with a superb bourbon selection and pretty good cigar choices. Other than that, there are Cigar Haven, Carmack's and The Cigar Box. Cigar Haven is about 20 minutes north of downtown Indy. Pretty good selection but mediocre lounge area. Carmack's is another 10 minutes north of that in Noblesville. Another good selection and decent sized lounge area. The Cigar Box has your standard selection and only 4 chairs. All of these except Blend close around 7pm. Blend is open til midnight, possibly later on the weekends but never stayed that late.