I like SLR and Gispert (nat) coronas, Punch Royal Coronations (nat), HdM Sabrosas (mad), BF coronas, of course there's connies... I really enjoyed Placeres Inmensos for a good $0.50 cigar but FSS closed all of those out so I can't get any more. I've had a couple Holt's Big Leauge and Holt's #35 (Tabacalera Tropical, makes these I believe) -- I think they're tasty.
If you con't mind machine mades, Muniemaker Brevas (mad) are nice but sometimes a little difficult to burn. The 4 John Hay Diplomats I've had were all surprisingly good.