Wow GREAT review! That's some defined pallet you've got there! Does it take time to develop that kind of taste? I'm having trouble picking out flavors that are that specific. Is it just me? Or does it take years of smoking?
I think for me it helps that I like to try different foods and I like to cook, so I get exposed (and expose myself) to different flavors and smells: spices, fruits, meats, etc. I also have a pretty good memory. Also, smoking slowly, not puffing too hard or quickly, is a good way to keep the smoke cool and allow the subtleties to reveal themselves. And unless I'm hanging out with my friends, I also drink nothing but water while smoking so no other flavors interfere.
Having said that, a lot of the flavors and aromas one gets from smoking is very subjectivenot in the sense that it's up to you whether you like the smoke or not, but rather that cigars can call to mind your own experiences and the sensations you attribute to them, so sometimes what you're
sensing (at least in my experience) can actually be an amalgam of a number of different things.
For instance, sometimes I taste lavender in cigars; I know what lavender smells like, but my main reference point are some old scratch 'n sniff stickers I used to have as a kid (for some reason, that smell is really vivid for me).
That smell for me defines lavender. The way the maple and oak trees smelled in the woods I used to play in as a kid is also the main reference point when I taste wood. Sometimes a vague quality about a cigar's bouquet makes me remember certain people, sometimes they make me remember the way I felt reading certain books or watching certain films for the first time . . . these in turn call to mind other memories, the phases of my life and the objects and people that have populated them, and the smoke becomes an experience that transcends the purely physiological phenomenon of taste and smellremember, smells are the quickest and most immediate paths to memory.
I think one thing to keep in mind is to not get bogged down in getting the flavor profile "right." The best cigars, for me, are the ones that make me daydream, think, and remember-sometimes in spite of what the cigar actually tastes and smells like. Sure, thoughts can be induced by the smoke's more "objective" qualities, but what I think is more important is the way the cigar makes me feel and what it makes me think.
Does it really matter if what you're actually tasting is raspberries as opposed to black currants? Or if you describe a certain tangy bite as licorice instead of anise seed? Maybe. But if, for whatever reason, raspberries is what you taste, and it's pleasurable to you because of it, then great!
At best, cigars can be a heavily meditative experience, and though I think refining one's palate is important, I think being able to sink back into your own head and really think and allow yourself to get lost in the smoke is even more rewarding than being able to compile a complete and "accurate" list of the smoke's flavors and scents....