I got a pair of those and they're fairly decent and do the job. They're not as good quality as the Xikars or Cigar Caddies but do the job. The foam inside is flimsy and not as good as the one's you find in Xikar and Cigar Caddy boxes and won't fit cigars over a 46RG.. I get the feeling they reduced the width of the flutes to maximize storage space but even with that it won't store 40 sticks but will hold around 30 depending on RG. Given the price I picked them up at it was a no brainer so can't complain about much here.
I'm presently looking to replace the foam inside these as I don't like the quality they put in and am not sure if its open cell or not.