How do you personally define a great cigar?

[icehog3]

Much like Safariman and some others, for me a great cigar is pretty simple:

Tastes great
Burns great
Draws great

If it tastes good, burns good and draws good, it's a good cigar. If it doesn't make good on any of those criteria, it's a bad cigar.

 

[jasonatjl]

Two words: Gurkha Beast.

 

[multi-useless]

A great cigar to me is one that:

Feels good in the hand

Fits nicely in my mouth

I don't have to draw too hard on

Stays firm while I'm smoking it

Tastes good

Doesn't get smoke in my eye

 

[Old Smokey]

If I find myself looking at the cigar I am smoking and think, "man, this really a great cigar", then to me it is a great cigar. If a "WTF" or if the word "shit" enters my thoughts, it is not a great cigar.
And just because a specific cigar is great does not necessarily mean the next one will earn great status.

And it is known that @Glassman has nipples like large sugar cookies. 3 large Sugar Cookies! No vanilla wafers on "that guy".

 

[bwhite220]

And it is known that @Glassman has nipples like large sugar cookies. 3 large Sugar Cookies! No vanilla wafers on "that guy".

...you just ruined Sugar Cookies for me.

 

[Glassman]

...you just ruined Sugar Cookies for me.

That's probably for the best..

 

[bwhite220]

That's probably for the best..

You’re a monster!

 

[VeLoRoK]

That's probably for the best..

He just called you fat @bwhite220

 

[Glassman]

He just called you fat @bwhite220

Hey, he held the door open, I couldn't help but walk through it..

 

[bwhite220]

He just called you fat @bwhite220

Hey, he held the door open, I couldn't help but walk through it..

Lucky for you, I’m too busy eating my 4th slice of pizza for today’s second lunch to be offended.

 

[Glassman]

Lucky for you, I’m too busy eating my 4th slice of pizza for today’s second lunch to be offended.

I was just trying to find that "here you go fat ass" meme card you sent me..

 

[bwhite220]

Sorry, @SurfnSafari. It appears that @Glassman and I have managed to derail another thread...

 

[Coincrazed]

Sorry, @SurfnSafari. It appears that @Glassman and I have managed to derail another thread...

If there was a trophy for derailment of threads, you and Glassman would have earned it by now! xD

 

[bwhite220]

If there was a trophy for derailment of threads, you and Glassman would have earned it by now! xD

glASSman, can you make a glass trophy?

 

[SurfnSafari]

Sorry, @SurfnSafari. It appears that @Glassman and I have managed to derail another thread...

I will hijack one of yours soon like Blackbeard the Pirate. So now you better watch your SIX. LOL.

 

[Glassman]

glASSman, can you make a glass trophy?

Why do I get the feeling I already know what you want it to look like.....

 

[bwhite220]

Why do I get the feeling I already know what you want it to look like.....

Uh, because we are BFF’s.

 

[acitalianman13]

This is how I define a good cigar
1- Has a ton of good flavors
2- has a good draw
3- burns great with no touch ups
4- doesn’t say Gurkha on the band