everyone stop their whining. people took advantage of an erroneous offer. it ain't the first time. don't be startled by the ugly side of a free market society. also, whether you think they're good or bad people because of their decision is a private matter. whether you think you're morally or ethically superior to them is a private matter. posting polls and responses to shame someone is poor taste. there's a lot of shady stuff that happens on here that never gets highlighted. take your gripes up with the brother directly - if you really think you need to. it ain't much of a brotherhood if you don't embrace the muck too.
the ch guy didn't have to honor it. he chose to and some people won out.
move on.
I agree what you decide to do is a private matter.....until you post in the internet for the whole friggin world to see. At that point you should expect the opposition, whoever that may be, to speak up. If you feel justified taking advantage of a small business owner, to save a few bucks, then that is your choice, and is a private one. When you publicly state, that you did this, then you should expect some to judge you.
I don't have a dog in this hunt, as this had already unfolded y the time I saw it. Maybe I have selective morals, as i would stick hold a big company to thier price, but CheapHumidors is not the Wal Mart of the cigar world. My guess is that the WalMarts of the cigar world would have told all of you to fly a kite with your orders.