So many great suggestions in this thread. Thanks for all the replies!
My local store has most of the brands listed, they just tend to be larger sizes. It gets a little frustrating because I really want the brand, I just don't need any more hour or more smokes for now.
The illusione 68 seemed just a little too large, and the small padron was an 11.00 cigar.
So far I have bought reinado habanito, tat petite, pcr, cabaiguan petite, oliva special g, dogwalker. I'm still planning on picking up the short story.
The next chance I get to go around to some different locals, I'll bring a list from this thread and see what I can find.