T52 Vs. #9...Which is stronger?

[Clint]

I've smoked just one T52 toro out of my recent purchase, and within a week or so I've smoked 3 of the Liga #9 Toro.

To my palate, there is a significant difference between the two. The T52 is substantially spicier and stronger than the #9. By comparison, the #9 seems lackluster.

I read a few reviews that pegged the T52 as milder, so I thought I'd see what others have noticed.

(Yeah, I know....Everyone has different tastes, but thought this would be interesting to see what a poll would reveal)

Thanks for your input!

 

[e-man67]

Different strokes I guess...I don't care for the 52 at all but really like the #9.

 

[PLUSH]

Different strokes I guess...I don't care for the 52 at all but really like the #9.

See, I'm the other way round. I think the T52 is stronger and have smoked 5 within the last week.

 

[Slidzero]

To me they are fairly similar. The #9 is a little more rough around the edges and the T52 is more refined and balanced. I love both but the #9 has a little more power and the T52 is a little more subtle and nuanced.

 

[Alwayslit]

Like both......t-52 seems to have more finesse than the #9. Really depends on my mood which one I'll smoke.

 

[Dread]

Ive only had 2 T52's and both seemed a bit stronger than the #9. While I find both to be full flavored I think in body the #9 is closer to medium whereas the T52 is more on the full end of the spectrum.

 

[Thegreekone]

To me they are fairly similar. The #9 is a little more rough around the edges and the T52 is more refined and balanced.

+1

I still think that the T52 is a bit "bigger" of a smoke, but neither are harsh. My first LP was a #9 "pig" and it was incredible. My first T52 was the robusto, so maybe my experiences have been shaped by size as well.


I am about to revisit #9 pig before T52 comes out and I have some T52 Toros on the way. I will share my experinces this weekend with the pig.

 

[Clint]

Ahhh, the pig! That T52 pig "should" be awesome.

 

[Slidzero]

+1

I still think that the T52 is a bit "bigger" of a smoke, but neither are harsh. QUOTE]


I'm not saying that the #9 is harsh by any means, just that the T52 is a little more refined and nuanced.

 

[bigbwalls]

To me, the T52 is much stronger of a smoke than the No. 9. The first few puffs of a T52 is all spice and pepper and it's a kick to the back of the throat.

Both are wonderful cigars, well worth the money that everyone should try. But -- like most -- I'll have to give the nod to the T52.

 

[DaCan23]

I completely agree with you.

To me they are fairly similar. The #9 is a little more rough around the edges and the T52 is more refined and balanced. I love both but the #9 has a little more power and the T52 is a little more subtle and nuanced.

 

[bmony]

I like them both but for my pallette I give the #9 the edge just by a hair.

 

[smokinpeace]

Different strokes I guess...I don't care for the 52 at all but really like the #9.

This is my take as well.

 

[danthebugman]

I think they're both top notch, but generally have found the T52 to be a little stronger. My preference is for the #9. I get many of the same flavors from both the T52 and the #9 so I don't find the added strength of the T52 to be all that important. That said, I do enjoy both :grin:.

Dan

 

[megladon8]

Tim from Burning Leaf hooked me up with a few toro's of each (the T52 and the No. 9) which I am eagerly awaiting.

From what I gather, though, I'll have to eat a nice big meal beforehand. They both sound like real powerhouses.

 

[SmokeProper]

Just smoked a no9. Good unique flavors. Wouldn't say it's real strong, not as strong/heavy as the tat cojonu.
Haven't had any of the 5 t52s I have yet.

 

[mwlabel]

I found the t52 to be stronger than the 9. but i have, like many, heard it go either way.

 

[Greyghost]

T52= big dinner. #9= light lunch.

 

[Jonathan Drew]

My impressions:

T52 - Much more Spicey, Brighter and Stronger than the LP#9.

LP#9 - Rounder than T52, with a bold Nicaraguan Earth core.

JD4 - Combination of T52 and LP#9, but stepped up a notch in strength, like a jacked up Rat.

Best,
JD

 

[rabbgp]

My impressions:

T52 - Much more Spicey, Brighter and Stronger than the LP#9.

LP#9 - Rounder than T52, with a bold Nicaraguan Earth core.

JD4 - Combination of T52 and LP#9, but stepped up a notch in strength, like a jacked up Rat.

Best,
JD

Perfect description, but then what would you expect? :grin: