Ok so if you oculd only have one would it be a punch, v cutter, or straight cutter? I love the punch and the v cutter but know once and a while you might have aneed to use a straight cutter. I want to buy one cutter right now and gift the one the cigar shop gave me to my buddy that likes cigars as well.. Giving him a few sticks from what I have to get him started. ANd if you say v cutter how do the colibri and the xikar xv2 compare. I had bad experiences with colibri lighters in the past.