Well, good thing is that there's a lot of great stuff out there between 5 - 8. That punch looks alright, but I haven't tried many of the NC (non-cuban) versions of CC (cuban) brands, just to minimize confusion for myself. Sounds like you're in a medium-medium (body-strength) place right now. I tend to lean towards fuller bodied stuff and dark rich maduro stuff, but I can think of a few things you can try.
There are some great samplers out there right now, I really think famous, Puro cigar, and Atlantic are the best place for samplers. I've had better luck with the midrange ones rather than the budget ones, less fluff to discard. For a large company CAO really does put out some good stuff, I think the Brazilia, Pilon, mx2, are great (but I'm a maduro guy), I'd definitely recommend both of the main "Crowned Heads" samplers that are out there. Famous' "Auctioneer" site is a great place for those.
Atlantic has an excellent Curivari sampler, as well as a pete johnson sampler and aj fernandez sampler available. Speaking of AJ, a lot of people are really liking his stuff. Cigars.com has a sampler special of his primary line for a great deal + free shipping right now, probably only gonna be up for another couple of days -
https://www.cigars.com/deal/aj-fernandez-humi-bag-collection-only-24-95 , they also have a caldwell sampler deal that looks good.
And over at Purocigar.com you can get some of the best deals on premium boutique sticks with their botl code and free shipping, putting them down closer to budget prices. Highly recommend grabbing the Illusione sampler, as well as the romacraft intemperance BAXXVi, great stick.
Have fun man! - Jeremy