Just found this thread. This is a good one! I see how someone could feel there are shills for certain brands. I don't think it's really the case but I understand. When you really get down to it, "WE" really only focus on a few brands that are out there. That being said I think there is a reason why that is. Similar to music or beer or...anything almost, the majority of what is out there is homogeneous and boring. They may make quality cigars but there is a feeling of "so what?" Certain brands have changed the game slightly by changing the dynamic of the overall cigar experience. These companies should be supported for chaning the game as much as some companies should be supported for remaining authentic, what ever that may be.
I do notice that this being a communal environment of sorts, people want to fit in and be in certain circles. Purchases are made. Purchases are shown. The same people later turn around and sell off those HTF cigars. So it leads me to believe that some, in the need to fit in, buy cigars they don't need or can't afford because of the hype and cool guy factor of being one of the few to have held such a limited release, even if only for a limited time.
I know the feeling. I recently had to have an honest talk with myself and admit that I really do not need the newest Monster series.
To the point of the poll, I do factor in some reviews. If a person has some similar tastes as myself or is completely honest in what they did or did not like/experience I might try it based on just that.