Thanks guys. I'm not necessarily looking for something that taste like cigars, what I meant was a full flavor. Couple of the tobaccos I've tried so far have been pretty mild, lacking in the flavor department.
ak2000, Please read this knowing that I come from about 37 years enjoying both pipes and cigars.
I think you are going to be disappointed if you are looking for something in a pipe tobacco that will be as full flavored as a cigar.
Why, you ask?
Know this, a cigar produces quite a bit more smoke than a pipe does, that is just by nature the difference from pipe and cigar. Part of that is the tobaccos used, part of that is the design of a pipe versus the design of a cigar, and the simple physics of how much oxygen gets to the burning ember (cherry of the pipe or cigar).
There are a couple things you can do to get "more full flavor" out of a pipe than you have gotten from it so far.
First, your expectations. A cigar is smoked, the flavors are right there, out in the open. A pipe however is meant to be "sipped" while smoking, it is the subtle flavors that are present which make a pipe so enjoyable.
Now, having said all that, I will direct you to some "fuller flavored/higher nicotine" pipe tobaccos. There have been some already named, but if you want to get down to some of the fullest-bodied, with an incredible nicotine hit, then consider the following ideas. Gawith & Hoggarth makes some very strong/full bodied tobaccos: Black Irish X Twist, Brown Irish X Twist, Brown Bogi (or Happy Bogies), Dark Birdseye, and Louisiana Flake.
Samuel Gawith also makes some decently strong tobaccos: 1792, Best Brown, Black XX, Full Virginia Flake, St. James Flake.
Hope this helps!
Peace of the Lord be with you.