I'm a newbie here (I smoke 6-8 cigars a year, hoping to get serious about this and make that more frequent). I just got some samplers and on this page alone I see 4 I have in my humi and haven't tried (Papas Fritas, Jericho Hill, Ilusione Rothchilde, and Flor de Antillas). They sound wonderful and I can't wait to try them - amazing prices on these, and it says a lot that people consider them staples. Thanks for validating my choices, everyone!
Of what I have gotten to inspect more closely I'll add AF Short Stories to the list too. I love a short smoke and it's such a well-rounded, well-built cigar in a tiny package. I'm also a sucker for a tapered foot in the winter time to make lighting easier!