Cigar Aficionado Top 25 for 2011
- Thread starter MU Mike
- Start date
Sorry, I'll try to do better... :disappoin
I thought I did well, yesterday, sidetracking the discussion....
I think that's likely the majority opinion.
Craig Mac
BoM 4/10 7/11 12/14
Yeah man, what the hell? You're messing up the vibe here bro :fencing:
That's what I'm wondering....
:scratchhe
I heard they didn't get a chance to smoke any Fuente's this year... someone else hoarded them all.
If I were reaching for an Epernay, I doubt I would reach for that size.
Has an Anejo ever made the top 5 slot? I guess CA does not rate them very often. One of the best lines of cigars out there period IMHO, especially with age.
As for what has a legit chance of being #1, though, I have no clue. What haven't they covered? Little chance of them having 3 Cubans in the top 10, right, so it'll be NC?
As for what has a legit chance of being #1, though, I have no clue. What haven't they covered? Little chance of them having 3 Cubans in the top 10, right, so it'll be NC?
njstone
BoM January 2010
Probably the Padron 44th Natural. Could always be an Opus, of course.
I'm actually more impressed with this list than I thought I would be thus far. The Warlock, RP 15th, and Punch DC I haven't had, so cannot comment on those. But the rest are good cigars.
ericdriscoll
CRA Ambassador #175966
I agree Anejo's are wonderful with age however they do not rate cigars with that kind of age on them. Also past years Anejo's have not been wonderful nor consistent. I have smoked a ton of Anejo's since they came out and since CA rates for consistent quality with each non blind smoke I can see how these fall short. In my many smoking years I have seen this. Smoked an '04 Anejo #55 last night that was wonderful.
Show off!!!:smokingbo
ericdriscoll
CRA Ambassador #175966
Lol. When now I've just put back the one I was going to gift you this evening.
That's fine I prefer the stuff from the top shelf and the drawers anyway.:tongueout
I am really happy to see the Epernay Le Taureau on the list, I was really impressed with that size. Normally I don't care for a cigar quite that big, but the box press really made it a very manageable smoke. I only got to smoke one of them so far and I cant wait to smoke more.