I prefer a punch, I have always chosen my cigars based upon that I don't want to use a cutter, only a punch. Until a couple of days ago my buddy Brutus here on the forum he introduced me to a guilatine cutter that has a hole on the other side that the torpedo tip fits into and the rest is a standard cutter so I can do torpedo and I don't have to worry about taking too much off and not perfectly square. Well I don't know where he got this cutter but I have opened myself up to more variety of smokes now cuz of it. I still like the punch though. I never tried the cross cut, afraid of messing up a good stick.