SkinsFanLarry
Craft Beer Addict!
- Joined
- Oct 14, 2008
- Messages
- 14,355
:thumbsup: We have a winner!!!! :thumbsup:EPC Short Run and LP T52 should have both been on there.
:thumbsup: We have a winner!!!! :thumbsup:EPC Short Run and LP T52 should have both been on there.
You saying you don't like CA because they don't rate Ligas is is straight up false. I'm sorry but you need to look a little further before making statements like that. Look we all have different tastes. You like Ligas while I haven't found one that does much for me including Dirty Rats etc... I don't agree with all their ratings but can't say I hate them just like I don't agree with all Brooks ratings but you don't see me saying I hate SmokingStogie because Brooks hasn't rated "X" cigar.Well, there are many reasons I dislike C.A. but the main ones are this:
1) They don't review Liga Privada at all. The T52 is #1, baby!
2) They (allegedly) only smoke one inch of the cigars they review. That's like giving the final report on the Superbowl after the first quarter.
Ditto, I think I've smoked a total of 1 on that list anyways. I bet each of us could do our own lists and most of them would be different anyways.I could give a flying f**k...that was my vote :cbig:
"affordable" - wow, everyone has a bigger wallet than me!!! <lol>The T52 should've been on there. It's damn good and, lo and behold, affordable??
Agreed, very sad.CA no likey Liga Privada... <shrug> But I must admit I am mystified by their continual 88 for the line. And no rating on the Dirty Rat yet... I am betting it gets an 88... :>
I don't know sounds like sour grapes to me.Agreed, very sad.
Dan
You think the Camacho that made the cut is a better cigar then the T-52 or the Dirty Rat?I don't know sounds like sour grapes to me.
Good pointIt appears they haven't been rated yet, so how could they make the list? Dirty rat that is.
Well, as I said, I have not smoked the Camacho, but I find it hard to believe it is better then the T-52 to my tastes...T-52 is a good stick, but there are many sticks that could have made the list but didn't that are as good or better than a T52 IMO. We all know it's a fucked up list, but it's their list, just like yours is yours and so on. It is curious though, you haven't smoked the Camacho but still think the T52 should still be rated instead of it, maybe smoke the Camacho and see why it made the list, then criticize after. Would like to see a review on it. Actually what would be cool is for you to smoke the top 25 and see what your opinion is compared to theirs and post, that would be a good read. It gives the readers of your site and CA an opportunity to see where some of your differences will lie in relation to CA.
Haven't tried the Camacho but if I go by the ones I have smoked I'm sure I'll dislike it.You think the Camacho that made the cut is a better cigar then the T-52 or the Dirty Rat?