What's new

the OE15 Dog Rocket Challenge!!!

Rating - 100%
62   0   0
Joined
Feb 4, 2015
Messages
2,863
View attachment 63299

Obsidian Black. It's been sitting in my humidor for a couple years. The age did not help.
LOL, I have a love/hate relationship with Obsidian. I love that I can get fivers on cbid for 7 bucks. I hate that I'm usually disappointed with them and only end up smoking the first third or so. Usually I'm not so slow-headed as to keep smoking sticks that routinely disappoint, but every now and then I find myself really enjoying them... Can't figure it out...
 
Rating - 100%
45   0   0
Joined
Sep 9, 2014
Messages
1,722
Location
North Haven, CT
LOL, I have a love/hate relationship with Obsidian. I love that I can get fivers on cbid for 7 bucks. I hate that I'm usually disappointed with them and only end up smoking the first third or so. Usually I'm not so slow-headed as to keep smoking sticks that routinely disappoint, but every now and then I find myself really enjoying them... Can't figure it out...
I didn't nub it, but I smoked it into the 3/3. I hope the kids in Esteli appreciate it :)

It wasn't horrible, but I would definitely not smoke one without some incentive...
 
Rating - 100%
7   0   0
Joined
Jan 15, 2015
Messages
2,924
Location
NC, USA
I smoked a Ramon Bueso Odyssey today. WellI smoked a third on the way home from work. The whole thing tasted so young and green it was more than I could handle. I tossed it pulling into the driveway.

The wrapper still had about a half dozen green spots on it. All I could taste was grass and hay with a side of something undefinable. It tastes like they didn't even bother to finish fermenting the tobacco.
 
Rating - 100%
62   0   0
Joined
Feb 4, 2015
Messages
2,863
I smoked a Ramon Bueso Odyssey today. WellI smoked a third on the way home from work. The whole thing tasted so young and green it was more than I could handle. I tossed it pulling into the driveway.

The wrapper still had about a half dozen green spots on it. All I could taste was grass and hay with a side of something undefinable. It tastes like they didn't even bother to finish fermenting the tobacco.
Now I feel kinda bad - I think I bombed you one of those! First time I tried the Odyssey I liked it, then I smoked another one about a week ago and it was crap... Oh well, at least we supported a good cause. (y)
 

c.ortiz108

The fly in the ointment.
Rating - 100%
14   0   0
Joined
Jul 21, 2014
Messages
832
Location
NM
Now I feel kinda bad - I think I bombed you one of those! First time I tried the Odyssey I liked it, then I smoked another one about a week ago and it was crap... Oh well, at least we supported a good cause. (y)
I've heard pretty much only bad things about those. Too bad because the Genesis was great.
 
Rating - 100%
7   0   0
Joined
Jan 15, 2015
Messages
2,924
Location
NC, USA
Multi, this one was from a friend at work. He gave me a couple of sticks as payback for a bomb I dropped on him. You said all of the Buesos you sent needed time. So, they're getting it.

If they're inconsistent, maybe that one will be awesome.
 
Rating - 100%
41   0   0
Joined
Feb 11, 2015
Messages
3,722
Location
Joplin, MO
Ok so I hope this is still going on. Here goes. My first somewhat review.
Casa de Garcia nicaragua robusto

Pre light had citrus, cream and very slight pepper finish that lingered.

First third
Cream still there with a slight sweet tobacco flavor and mild leather. Retro is super mild and basically brings nothing to the game.
Second third
Sweetness is gone cream mellowing out. Picking up on the leather with a little spice.

Final third
Spice is gone just slight cream and mainly a lightly sweet tobacco flavor. Retro remained super mild and pointless.
Time was a little over an hour.
Overall impression
super mild smoke not horrible. I use these as give away smokes and they are good for that or else a yard gar. Not super complex by any means.
 
Rating - 100%
62   0   0
Joined
Feb 4, 2015
Messages
2,863
OK gents, we are 1 week in and 13 dog rockets smoked. That's only $13, so I'm upping the ante. :)

If your dog rocket is uber gross and/or we get a full review, I'll double down and make your effort worth $2. "Uber gross" is totally subjective, so I'll be the ref on that.

The bonus points will be added both retroactively, as well as moving forward... so, week in review: 13 sticks + 7 bonus points puts us at an even $20. Still plenty of time left - let's go for at least $100!
 
Rating - 100%
42   0   0
Joined
Sep 13, 2014
Messages
5,017
Location
Pennsy
Oh Man.
I have something. It's not going to be pretty. I bought these knowing they would be yard gars.
But these weren't yard gars. They weren't worthy of my yard. They weren't worthy of a junk yard.
They weren't worthy of Scotland Yard. Or the bone yard for that matter. .....
 
Rating - 100%
62   0   0
Joined
Feb 4, 2015
Messages
2,863
Oh Man.
I have something. It's not going to be pretty. I bought these knowing they would be yard gars.
But these weren't yard gars. They weren't worthy of my yard. They weren't worthy of a junk yard.
They weren't worthy of Scotland Yard. Or the bone yard for that matter. .....
ROFL, the anticipation is killing me...
 
Rating - 100%
1   0   0
Joined
May 3, 2015
Messages
20
Location
Columbia, SC
Alrighty. My first review on BOTL. And thank goodness it's for a dog rocket, where my snark can outweigh my evolving knowledge of all things stogie.
This was one of the CI Dominican Grab Bag sticks that we had all had a good groan over earlier in the week. I thought it was called HERPA, as that is all the test on the label visible. Not until the misery was over and I pulled off the label, did I discover it was actually a SHERPA. And considering the taste, it doesn't surprise me that I had a Sherpa stick in my mouth for an hour. Now go read that last line again.
As I mentioned in my Grab Bag post, one of my 5 packs showed up looking stepped on or run over. This stick wasn't even in that 5 pack and still looks bad. The shape is almost oval, though not intentional. It was packed tightly next to a shorter and thinner stick and it started to form around it, like a tree growing around a bicycle. Further evidence of this is in the foot, where a long craggy fault stretched across what should have been a happy place; strangely reminiscent of my first girlfriend, back in Jersey.
Pre-light draw was just gross. It had strong notes of kitchen compost in the summer. I reconsidered smoking this. But hey, you only live once, right? And if I spoke this, some other guy's gonna give a dollar to someone else. 'Merica!
The garbage taste went away after the first few draws, for which I will be forever thankful. That changed into 3 day grass mulch and wet hay. That kept up for the first third. After that, it became pretty tasteless (or my taste buds had fled my tongue) and I stopped a little into the last third, happy to be alive. Soon the hallucinations should stop, so I should go return this unicorn to it's owner on Ganymede.

label.jpg her-stick.jpg pa-stick.jpg foot.jpg 2015-05-09 00.40.05 [1600x1200].jpg
 
Rating - 100%
62   0   0
Joined
Feb 4, 2015
Messages
2,863
Alrighty. My first review on BOTL. And thank goodness it's for a dog rocket, where my snark can outweigh my evolving knowledge of all things stogie.
This was one of the CI Dominican Grab Bag sticks that we had all had a good groan over earlier in the week. I thought it was called HERPA, as that is all the test on the label visible. Not until the misery was over and I pulled off the label, did I discover it was actually a SHERPA. And considering the taste, it doesn't surprise me that I had a Sherpa stick in my mouth for an hour. Now go read that last line again.
As I mentioned in my Grab Bag post, one of my 5 packs showed up looking stepped on or run over. This stick wasn't even in that 5 pack and still looks bad. The shape is almost oval, though not intentional. It was packed tightly next to a shorter and thinner stick and it started to form around it, like a tree growing around a bicycle. Further evidence of this is in the foot, where a long craggy fault stretched across what should have been a happy place; strangely reminiscent of my first girlfriend, back in Jersey.
Pre-light draw was just gross. It had strong notes of kitchen compost in the summer. I reconsidered smoking this. But hey, you only live once, right? And if I spoke this, some other guy's gonna give a dollar to someone else. 'Merica!
The garbage taste went away after the first few draws, for which I will be forever thankful. That changed into 3 day grass mulch and wet hay. That kept up for the first third. After that, it became pretty tasteless (or my taste buds had fled my tongue) and I stopped a little into the last third, happy to be alive. Soon the hallucinations should stop, so I should go return this unicorn to it's owner on Ganymede.

View attachment 63668 View attachment 63669 View attachment 63670 View attachment 63671 View attachment 63666
Hahahaha, that was great! :ROFLMAO:

You, sir, are a trooper - way to hang in there brother, sticks and reviews like that are the kind that I'm doubling down on! 2 bucks to the kids of Esteli! (y)
 
Rating - 100%
1   0   0
Joined
May 3, 2015
Messages
20
Location
Columbia, SC
Having safely returned from Ganymede, I slammed down a quart of Cranberry Horseradish Detox and slept. My dreams were of a Sherpa, following a unicorn up Mt. Everest, collecting it's droppings and packing them into tubes marked 5 Vegas. I awoke refreshed, ready to smoke another dog rocket for the sake of all mankind.
Today's culprit, F&Z Primo #5. A cigar I have never heard of, and according to Google neither has anyone else. Actually, not true. I did find one mention of it on Nano's Cigar List (https://goo.gl/5xi1Y5) a Google Doc. Nano says "Another unknown cigar....not much can be found. It's okay, but not one I could recommend others to smoke".
The pre-light....oh dear, the pre-light. It was earthy but not just that. It made me ill, but kept triggering a memory from my youth. Not a pleasant one, but one I needed to figure out. Dammit. Now on a mission, I drew in this horrid air for a good 5 minutes. Trying to think back to my childhood on the farm. What crazy scent was I picking up?! Pig pen? Nope. Greenhouse? Nope. Packing house? Nah. Root cellar? No..but wait! Root...root..almost have it..YES! Beets. The pre-light taste was beets. I was so proud and disgusted.
So having determined that this unknown Dominican stick tasted like my least favorite vegetable. I lit that mutha up. And in truth, eh, not a completely horrible smoke. Mild, and earthy. But here's the thing, the problem I have with this cigar... let me put it this way. Here's is someone's list of 20 best beet recipes. They're in the UK, so I take their word on bad tasting food. http://www.brit.co/beet-dishes/
The problem with all of these recipes, from the Beet Crust Pizza to the The Beet Tzatziki Feta Fennel Chickpea Parsley Sandwich is that there are beeeeeeeets in them.


fz1.jpg Yuk.jpg
 

Attachments

Last edited:
Rating - 100%
42   0   0
Joined
Sep 13, 2014
Messages
5,017
Location
Pennsy
My Dog Rocket for the challenge was the CU-AVANA 7x50 ChurchHill. Guess I am supposed to believe this is CUban-hAVANA build. A quick google and it looks like C.I. actually carries this disgraceful stick.

The squeeze on this stick is pretty hard, doesn't have much give to it. This would be a laughable statement except I know what's in store for me here. This thing doesn't even smell good. It's like the smell that hits you when you get a box of shoes at the department store and open the box to try them on. .. A smell of rubber and leather. Smells like this thing was manufactured in a porn store. That's not good news either.
I had one of these about 7 months ago and threw it away after five minutes. Four more have been aging, awaiting Devine Intervention, on the floor of my humidor. Partially because tray space is a premium and cigars I don't smoke won't get valet parking in the Bondo-dor. But more likely I kept the bastarded sticks on the bottom so they would not contaminate anything else. Stored at 65RH, it shouldn't be dried out. The gillotine cutter chopped, the shoulder started to unravel. So I peeled that off. Pre draw also some slight resistance. WTF is with this thing? It's like a stick .
[FIRST TURD] 1:50PM - Paired beverage is a Coke Zero. Quite appropriate, since I expect zero out of this cigar.
Dog rocket lit, and onward we go !! with pure tobacco enjoyment !.
Already, It's on like Donkey Wrong ! The smoke production is lame, weak whisps of smoke. More like a cigarette. And this thing is a bat.. so go figure. Plus, it's an ugly, noxious, blue smoke off the cigar. I'm serious. Tried a couple of pictures, it's hard to see. But it was pretty obvious in the sun today. The draw resists a little. This is like trying to smoke a dowell.

Well, here's a picture of me trying to get through the "first turd".. I am trying to identify this profile. But it is more like a "nofile". It's not the bean - nut... It's not earth - barnyard.... It's not spice.... nothing on the 'flavor wheel' categories for this unpleasant taste on my lips, that makes me think there is a Crayola Crayon in here. This cigar would make a cigar beetle consider a career change. I am really fighting the urge to get away from this smoking concoction of wrapped refuse. My only salvation are the periodic Asparatame - Phenylalanine flushes from my Coke Zero.

[SECOND TURD] 2:20PM - Well, I'm just doing this for the MO Crew. And for the ESTI cause. But there is nothing smoke worthy at all about this. It is actually unenjoyable, and difficult to continue. The only way to endure this is to set goals. I'm going to keep going until 2:50 ( means 1 full hour smoking completed )... I'm going to keep going until I run out of Coke Zero. ( Oh God the beverage is necessary, believe me !!) or lastly, I finish the cigar, which is the most unlikely of the scenarios. I'll be dead first. They'll find me surrounded by a thin ghostly whisp of blue smoke as a testament to my stubborness.

Yeah sorry my hands are a little dirty. I did those front drilled slotted rotors for my wagon last week, and although the stuttering has ceased, the pedal feels a little spongy. The calipers are good but the passenger rear had a busted bleed screw. So today I bled it via the feed line. I think there's still air in there so I'm replacing it tomorrow.
OK so anyway, back to this disaster. During the "second turd" I figured out the flavor profile. You can sample it right right now. Go get the old style BIC pen with the removable cap. Chew on the cap for five minutes. Spit it out. Now. Taste that?
That's the flavor profile of this cigar. BIC Pen top.

"Licked 12 postage stamps taste" highlights on the retrohale..

[TURD TURD]2:50PM Well I just got into the last turd of this thng and saved by the bell !! It's been an hour, and I'm out of sweet, Pen Top chewing Chemical Soda Flush so I'm done.

I wanted an appropriate goodbye to this experience. On the internet there are these "cigar etiquette" articles. They say you should not squish a cigar when done. They say it is an insult to the cigar maker.
Well, looks like I may finally get some enjoyment out of this cigar, after all !!!

The insides of this thing. No BIC pen tops or crayons.


Smoke after flavorful smoke, Cu-Avana is consistently delicious and quite relaxing with nary a bad burn or dud in a dozen boxes. Despite the smooth and unobtrusive taste, there are some subtle yet distinct flavors of creamy spiciness, along with some coffee and almost lemon-like flavors, making this light cigar a treat you can enjoy any time of day.
 
Last edited:
Top