Fuente for me. I have to agree with Mu Mike. It has just as much to do with smoking experience or when you began smoking with where you fall on this vote I believe. When I started smoking Fuente was king and 858 maduro was one of my favorites. Then I moved up to the Hemi sigs. Another great cigar and they soon began making it in maduro also. Finally I found some Opus and Anejo. Something I always have to have around. Don't get me wrong I also love Tats. Pete makes some great smokes. The first cigar I smoked that I can remember was an 858 maddie. One of my fondest cigar memories. Sitting on a dock on the lake, fired the 858 up and I was sold. That is when I became a cigar smoker. If you really want to laugh I paid $1.25 for the cigar. Thats how long I have been smoking.